2010-2011: A Wasted Summer Part 1

A near 30 percent drop in average crowds. No finals football. The acrimonious loss of their Socceroo and star striker.

It wasn't the worst of times but the best of times faded pretty quickly this season for Sydney FC.

The A League has few real traditions but a swift stab in the back for under-performing Sydney managers is a seasonal delight. Viteslav Lavicka is very, very lucky to still be in a job. The Sydney FC overlords are to be commended for their restraint and thanked for their deep pockets.

Few others associated with the club deserve the same sentiment. Sydney is a city of high expectations (and lamentably low levels of supporter loyalty). For A League champions to miss the finals is not unprecedented but remains catastrophic. It is time to take stock.

The Asian Champions League can do more than salve the wounds from this campaign. It is time for the club to be decisive. It needs to jettison or play Stuart Musialik, Sung Hwan Byun and Stephan Keller. Lavicka needs to nurture or release Kofi Danning and find the best positions for Shannon Cole and Seb Ryall. He must pick and stick with one of Liam Reddy and Ivan Necevski.

Indecision has robbed Sydney FC of Matt Jurman - Lavicka should not be permitted to put his own short-term priorities ahead of future development. Lavicka's fight for survival is the bed that the board has made until the spring. Sydney will just have to live with it.

SQUAD REVIEW

GOALKEEPERS
Liam Reddy, Ivan Necevski

Australian football seems best at generating goalkeepers and to have a mediocre keeper is unacceptable. Reddy and Necevski were frustratingly inconsistent throughout this season and while both bore the cost of shaky shifts put in by those in front of them, neither seized the position with anything like the determination and confidence displayed so often by Clint Bolton. Reddy was very poor at times, particularly against North Queensland when he failed to read the obvious intentions of David Williams, while Necevski seems unable to grasp a cross or corner.

The decision to release Bolton, recruit Reddy and retain Necevski looks dodgy, particularly given the need for stability at the back with the obvious departure of Simon Colosimo (who was contemplating a trip overseas for months). It may have been a question of timing and wages, but there are better keepers home and abroad. Would it be too rude to mention Danny Vukovic?

CENTRAL DEFENCE
Hayden Foxe, Stephan Keller, Seb Ryall, Matt Jurman, Antony Golec, Andrew Durante (loan)

The source of many of Sydney's woes. The decision to replace the ball-playing Simon Colosimo with the skilled but slow-footed Hayden Foxe put Lavicka in a constant tactical bind. A central pairing of Foxe and Stephan Keller was extremely vulnerable to the pacy attacks of early season foes. Last season's high line and compact defence evaporated early. Too often the last line was left too deep to intercept but too high to recover, and Seb Ryall's inconsistencies and weakness in the air cost him his place - somewhat unfairly, in my opinion, as some of Keller's displays were particularly dire. Matt Jurman's emergence as a talented compromise candidate came too late to save Sydney's season and his departure is one to mourn.

The centrebacks were not assisted by unusually poor form from the screening Stuart Musialik and the ball holding target man Mark Bridge, but the end of the Asian Champions League campaign will bring a real challenge to the Sky Blue backline. Odds are that Keller, Foxe, Jurman and Durante will all depart, leaving Ryall and Golec, who barely played at all this season, as the only specialist centrebacks for the next A League season. Sydney will plummet from over supply to a chronic shortage in an area where they seemed so well stocked just 18 months ago.

Of course we all expect the club to sign a new central defender soon but outstanding candidates are thin on the ground. Jade North is another undersized centreback who can be maddeningly inconsistent - a Ryall/North partnership would be vulnerable to tall, rough attacks and the players' own panic attacks on and off the ball. Sydney need to find a more permanent solution than Durante - a signing I applaud, but a stopgap measure none the less. Jamie Coyne is a long way from Simon Colosimo's level of ability, even taking into account Colosimo's poor season in Melbourne.

For a club to play two central defenders that are on their way out, or not even Sydney players to begin with, is more than a symptom of poor recruitment - it is counter productive in the long run.

FULL BACKS
Shannon Cole, Sung Hwan Byun, Scott Jamieson, (Seb Ryall)

Full back might be Sydney's strongest area going into Asia - an odd assertion given that Byun could be trimmed to make room for other foreigners and Ryall will rarely start matches at rightback.

In Shannon Cole and Scott Jamieson Sydney have a pair of fullbacks at home in the tackle, dogged over 90 minutes and happy to bomb forward with the ball at their feet.

Both have their limitations. Cole's attitude and ability in attack is sabotaged by some poor positioning and tendency to ball watch, while Jamieson's first touch and delivery from wide areas can be phenomenally dire. Jamieson is also rather one-footed and loses speed at the end of the second half.

But Lavicka's set up of a conservative midfield three behind a hard-running number 10 requires attack-minded fullbacks and there are few better suited to the task, or with more potential for improvement, than Cole and Jamieson (not that Josh Rose, Cassio or Shane Steffanuto are not slightly above the Sydney two).

If Sydney can settle on a midfield anchorman, a centreback combination and keep Nick Carle fit, Cole and Jamieson will find form and consistency. It was not easy for Cole to half-heartedly get forward as the ball was lost in midfield, or for Jamieson to start off as a left midfielder (a position he should never play again).

Ryall is too conservative a fullback for an already narrow team and Lavicka seems rightly unlikely to play him on the right unless the last 10 minutes require locking up. Byun will always be a Sydney hero but his second season will be remembered for yelling at his teammates and shrugging his shoulders.

The recruitment of a seasoned left back such as Dean Heffernan would simply retard Jamieson's progress in the same way that Cassio's brilliance forced him out of Adelaide. Sydney should find another solution, perhaps a left footed centreback who provides a defensive alternative, and continue to develop their two Australians. The whispered arrival of Scott Chipperfield could also work, provided Chipperfield plays in midfield and provides cover for injury.