It has taken this long to collect my thoughts on Sydney's remarkable bludgeoning of Brisbane on the weekend. October seems an age ago. Perhaps Viteslav Lavicka has rediscovered his side's spine.
Ground level seats by a corner post prevented me really seeing how the game unfolded (plus a Homebake hangover that endangered the cleanliness of said corner post), but certain things were obvious. After the shock of the early goal, Sydney closed down with coordinated intent. Their clear game plan was invigorated by Petratos' drive and the side shifted to each flank as one.
Brisbane only had Plan A and Sydney made a mockery of it. Safe possession was ceded to the Roar centrebacks but the fullbacks were sharked and the midfield shackled. Sydney forced the match into a 30 yard square and dared the Roar to stitch a passing path through them. Brisbane utterly failed to do so.
Sydney's "long ball" game was aided by strong gusts that pulled the Sky Blues' long passes back towards them. Bruno Cazarine won a fair share of headers while Dimi Petratos harried, hassled and won an unbelievable number of knock downs and 50/50s. Sydney sucked in the Brisbane midfield and then played the ball first time to space.
Once Sydney established their lead and willingness to gamble for scraps, they began to put their foot on the ball. Pascal Bosschaart, Shannon Cole, Karol Kisel, Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle were able to relieve the pressure of Brisbane possession, while Terry McFlynn and Jamie Coyne played their part.
Liam Reddy is a man transformed. The intense keeper has built a platform of form and confidence from his strong opening match against the Victory and orders the side around like a tyrant. In front of him Michael Beauchamp and Pascal Bosschaart played the match Sydney fans have been waiting to see. They resisted Brisbane's attempts to pull them apart and some of Bosschaart's distribution bordered on the ridiculous and/or miraculous. Can the Cove finally forget Simon Colosimo?
Shannon Cole slotted in for the suspended Scott Jamieson and the left footer might be hard-pressed to win his spot back. Cole grew into the game and his swashbuckling forays in the second half caught the eye while some in the crowd caught their breath. One little run that led to a freekick was particularly risky but Cole looked immaculate in defence and his kamikaze block must make him undroppable.
It would be harsh to drop Jamie Coyne, who did little wrong and lends much needed height at set pieces, but Cole offers courage, technique and panache. If he does get left on the bench, expect to see him on at halftime if Sydney are chasing the game.
Terry McFlynn led the side like never before. He lifted the crowd, mostly kept the ball safe and constantly encouraged the troops to left. When Petratos butchered a chance to play Bruno in, McFlynn talked the justifiably petulant Brazilian into pulling his head in. The A League has grown past the notion of McFlynn as an attacking midfielder, but he might be the anchorman to guide Sydney to glory.
I couldn't see too much of the midfield duel but all pundits seem to have praised how disciplined Sydney's most experienced players were. Carle, Emerton and Kisel are the type to relish taking on Australia's best and they will want to push the club forward.
Dimi Petratos was waiting for a chance to impress, and boy did he take it. It was an enormous shame that he couldn't take more - Petratos is not quite the predator we would wish him to be, but suddenly Sydney look strong across the front. Petratos' touch and turn make him more of a scheming midfielder than a beat-the-line speedster, but it is clear he has intrigued Lavicka and invigorated Bruno.
Mark Bridge and Terry Antonis will rightly find it hard to win a starting spot. Potential must be matched by performance in a team of Sydney's ambition.
Sydney have options all across the park, are relatively injury free and know they can beat the best team in Australian professional sporting history.
Brisbane were well below their best but Sydney won't care. They won, won with style, won the fans and know they can win a title. It is the leaders that will decide whether they build towards glory.
Sunday's success has led some to ask whether Sydney FC should move to Kogarah. The answer is in the title. Sydney is the city's football club and must play near its central station. A cozy suburb with a community stadium is a fantastic place to visit, but until someone builds Sydney's answer to AAMI Park at Redfern, the SFS is home.
Wednesday, December 7, 2011
Saturday, November 19, 2011
Mariners Rattle and Roll Over Sydney
Sydney FC's Socceroo-laden side was out-muscled, then out-hustled, and finally out-played on Saturday night. Central Coast were good value for their 3-2 win and Sydney FC must ponder some hard questions if they are to challenge for the title that "Football's Capital" surely deserves.
When Terry McFlynn left the field, perhaps succumbing to injury, perhaps to a tactical decision by Viteslav Lavicka, promising 17-year-old Terry Antonis was left to mind Daniel McBreen and a fierce Mariners outfit. Graham Arnold's side allowed Sydney a measure of harmless possession, then sharked at Mark Bridge whenever he received the ball at his feet.
The Mariners' winning goals were born from textbook transition play and when Arnold subbed McBreen for the wily Musti Amini a tiring Antonis was overwhelmed and eventually hooked. The youngster may have been overworked after Young Socceroos duties. Maybe he just had a shocker. Neither explanation should be surprising at Antonis' age, but Hiro Moriyasu might have been brought on earlier to stem the tide.
Antonis was far from Sydney's worst on a fairly forgettable night. Star marquee Brett Emerton endured a pretty average first half and was unable to shrug off Central Coast's disciplined defensive pattern. Like Antonis, Emerton should improve after a week's rest.
Michael Beauchamp was schooled by Matt Simon. Beauchamp was once selected for the Socceroos for his strength in the air and immovability on the ground. He was unable to win a header in the second half and his list of errors is starting to lengthen. Seb Ryall might start to fancy his chances of a recall at centre back, though that would leave a short Sydney team even more susceptible at set pieces.
Chris Coyne and Terry McFlynn did the dirty work, but Coyne did not take strong options with the ball at his feet and some of the passing from Sydney's "water carriers" was woeful. McFlynn was missed in the second half, particularly when the second goal was clipped in from the spot while Antonis was nowhere to be seen. Sydney will hope their captain can recover quickly - he provides the muscle that an A League competitor seems to need.
Mark Bridge seems to pop up in all the right places and then butcher all the best chances. He has never scored prolifically and is as likely to balloon a simple chance before playing an exquisite pass. Bridge failed at 10 last year and is, so far, failing at no 9. Bruno Cazarine is a man of slow feet and heavy touch but backs himself to score. Bridge fits better with Sydney's aspirations of play, but Bruno has scored 10 goals in 28 games. Bridge has 27 in 116.
Liam Reddy and Scott Jamieson built on their strong campaigns so far. Nicky Carle continues to impress but still seems more comfortable when he has more than one passing option in front of him. How to fit Carle, Emerton, Kisel, McFlynn and Antonis into a midfield diamond remains Lavicka's biggest dilemma. Right now he has decided to play his two marquee men out of position. Such a decision could be described as "courageous".
When Terry McFlynn left the field, perhaps succumbing to injury, perhaps to a tactical decision by Viteslav Lavicka, promising 17-year-old Terry Antonis was left to mind Daniel McBreen and a fierce Mariners outfit. Graham Arnold's side allowed Sydney a measure of harmless possession, then sharked at Mark Bridge whenever he received the ball at his feet.
The Mariners' winning goals were born from textbook transition play and when Arnold subbed McBreen for the wily Musti Amini a tiring Antonis was overwhelmed and eventually hooked. The youngster may have been overworked after Young Socceroos duties. Maybe he just had a shocker. Neither explanation should be surprising at Antonis' age, but Hiro Moriyasu might have been brought on earlier to stem the tide.
Antonis was far from Sydney's worst on a fairly forgettable night. Star marquee Brett Emerton endured a pretty average first half and was unable to shrug off Central Coast's disciplined defensive pattern. Like Antonis, Emerton should improve after a week's rest.
Michael Beauchamp was schooled by Matt Simon. Beauchamp was once selected for the Socceroos for his strength in the air and immovability on the ground. He was unable to win a header in the second half and his list of errors is starting to lengthen. Seb Ryall might start to fancy his chances of a recall at centre back, though that would leave a short Sydney team even more susceptible at set pieces.
Chris Coyne and Terry McFlynn did the dirty work, but Coyne did not take strong options with the ball at his feet and some of the passing from Sydney's "water carriers" was woeful. McFlynn was missed in the second half, particularly when the second goal was clipped in from the spot while Antonis was nowhere to be seen. Sydney will hope their captain can recover quickly - he provides the muscle that an A League competitor seems to need.
Mark Bridge seems to pop up in all the right places and then butcher all the best chances. He has never scored prolifically and is as likely to balloon a simple chance before playing an exquisite pass. Bridge failed at 10 last year and is, so far, failing at no 9. Bruno Cazarine is a man of slow feet and heavy touch but backs himself to score. Bridge fits better with Sydney's aspirations of play, but Bruno has scored 10 goals in 28 games. Bridge has 27 in 116.
Liam Reddy and Scott Jamieson built on their strong campaigns so far. Nicky Carle continues to impress but still seems more comfortable when he has more than one passing option in front of him. How to fit Carle, Emerton, Kisel, McFlynn and Antonis into a midfield diamond remains Lavicka's biggest dilemma. Right now he has decided to play his two marquee men out of position. Such a decision could be described as "courageous".
Monday, November 7, 2011
Kisel The Key Man
I missed the first half of Sydney FC's best game of the year thanks to a weekend stint in gaol. We arrived five minutes before halftime. The crowd was as I feared - restless, angry and smaller than it should be.
Sydneysiders sense their team's collective lack of belief. Last season the club scrapped and grappled for draws, in stark contrast to the team of two years ago who scored first and strangled teams into submission.
Viteslav Lavicka - surely the manager with the most to prove this season - identified the problem of a lack of leadership and re-recruited Karol Kisel before the close of a lost season. He beefed up Sydney's spine with Pascal Bosschaart and Michael Beauchamp, and the shock signing of Brett Emerton left Lavicka with as good a squad on paper as one could ask for: three Socceroos, three Young Socceroos, two former internationals and a host of home-grown footballers with lots to prove.
The opening arm wrestle against Melbourne was rich with promise - Sydney dominated much of the play until Mark Bridge's brain snap. The home fans endured a spanking from the Roar, but results against Adelaide and the Heart were encouraging.
What a shame it was that only 11 051 fans turned up on a gloomy Sunday afternoon to see Sydney wilt, straighten and run over Gold Coast United. It was the performance that proved Lavicka's point: he has more leaders. He can let the team off the leash because their capacity to entertain springs from mental strength.
I've previously called for Karol Kisel to be benched for Dimi Petratos and Terry Antonis. Kisel showed on Sunday exactly why he was the first player Lavicka wanted for this season. Kisel possesses belief, technique, nous and a competitive fire that spreads throughout the side.
It was Kisel, Carle and Emerton that forced Sydney FC back into the match after the calamitous second Gold Coast goal. They kicked the club into fifth gear. Passes previously delivered at a pedestrian pace skidded off the turf. Fullbacks were thrust forward while Terry McFlynn mopped up with venom.
I had figured that Kisel's inclusion would damage Sydney by forcing the messiah himself, Brett Emerton, out onto the left - a role which proved difficult against the Victory and the Roar. But Emerton proved his worth to Sydney on Sunday. His backheels, lay offs, flicks and driving runs inside and outside Gold Coast's defence pulled defenders away from Scott Jamieson, who has lifted his game this season. Perhaps Jamieson has been energized by some of the leadership that Lavicka was after. More could come from a raw, young talent.
The backline of Coyne, Bosschaart, Beauchamp and Jamieson seems settled but work is clearly required - Gold Coast's second goal would not have been out of place in an early edition of FIFA. United's forward movement often threatened to pinch a third goal - can a triangle of McFlynn, Bosschaart and Beauchamp keep up with a mobile threat?
Sydney's midfield is certainly mobile enough and technically adroit. Emerton, Nicky Carle, Karol Kisel and Terry McFlynn will take some replacing - though it was interesting that Lavicka did not decide to replace McFlynn with Rhyan Grant as the clock wore down. Instead Beauchamp galloped forward and won the crucial penalty after Gold Coast wrapped their legs around him.
Lavicka's biggest dilemma remains how to get the most out of Mark Bridge. The eternal enigma could have scored a hat trick and won a penalty, but took home nothing but the rage of the crowd after he blinked when Emerton bounced a cross towards his hip.
Some say that Bridge is the club's best natural finisher. It's time he proved it. With Bruno and Petratos nipping at his heels, to say nothing of the phantom Surgeon, Bridge will have to start taking opportunities.
Sydney's next home game is against their closest rivals - Central Coast, another side with a lot to prove. It will be a heated match but Sydney have the most cause to look forward to it. They know they can win tight matches by playing positive, ball on the ground football. They know Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle will only get better - Carle must be getting close to a Socceroos recall.
And Terry Antonis, one of the A League's brightest prospects, wasn't even playing on Sunday. This could be a great season.
Sydneysiders sense their team's collective lack of belief. Last season the club scrapped and grappled for draws, in stark contrast to the team of two years ago who scored first and strangled teams into submission.
Viteslav Lavicka - surely the manager with the most to prove this season - identified the problem of a lack of leadership and re-recruited Karol Kisel before the close of a lost season. He beefed up Sydney's spine with Pascal Bosschaart and Michael Beauchamp, and the shock signing of Brett Emerton left Lavicka with as good a squad on paper as one could ask for: three Socceroos, three Young Socceroos, two former internationals and a host of home-grown footballers with lots to prove.
The opening arm wrestle against Melbourne was rich with promise - Sydney dominated much of the play until Mark Bridge's brain snap. The home fans endured a spanking from the Roar, but results against Adelaide and the Heart were encouraging.
What a shame it was that only 11 051 fans turned up on a gloomy Sunday afternoon to see Sydney wilt, straighten and run over Gold Coast United. It was the performance that proved Lavicka's point: he has more leaders. He can let the team off the leash because their capacity to entertain springs from mental strength.
I've previously called for Karol Kisel to be benched for Dimi Petratos and Terry Antonis. Kisel showed on Sunday exactly why he was the first player Lavicka wanted for this season. Kisel possesses belief, technique, nous and a competitive fire that spreads throughout the side.
It was Kisel, Carle and Emerton that forced Sydney FC back into the match after the calamitous second Gold Coast goal. They kicked the club into fifth gear. Passes previously delivered at a pedestrian pace skidded off the turf. Fullbacks were thrust forward while Terry McFlynn mopped up with venom.
I had figured that Kisel's inclusion would damage Sydney by forcing the messiah himself, Brett Emerton, out onto the left - a role which proved difficult against the Victory and the Roar. But Emerton proved his worth to Sydney on Sunday. His backheels, lay offs, flicks and driving runs inside and outside Gold Coast's defence pulled defenders away from Scott Jamieson, who has lifted his game this season. Perhaps Jamieson has been energized by some of the leadership that Lavicka was after. More could come from a raw, young talent.
The backline of Coyne, Bosschaart, Beauchamp and Jamieson seems settled but work is clearly required - Gold Coast's second goal would not have been out of place in an early edition of FIFA. United's forward movement often threatened to pinch a third goal - can a triangle of McFlynn, Bosschaart and Beauchamp keep up with a mobile threat?
Sydney's midfield is certainly mobile enough and technically adroit. Emerton, Nicky Carle, Karol Kisel and Terry McFlynn will take some replacing - though it was interesting that Lavicka did not decide to replace McFlynn with Rhyan Grant as the clock wore down. Instead Beauchamp galloped forward and won the crucial penalty after Gold Coast wrapped their legs around him.
Lavicka's biggest dilemma remains how to get the most out of Mark Bridge. The eternal enigma could have scored a hat trick and won a penalty, but took home nothing but the rage of the crowd after he blinked when Emerton bounced a cross towards his hip.
Some say that Bridge is the club's best natural finisher. It's time he proved it. With Bruno and Petratos nipping at his heels, to say nothing of the phantom Surgeon, Bridge will have to start taking opportunities.
Sydney's next home game is against their closest rivals - Central Coast, another side with a lot to prove. It will be a heated match but Sydney have the most cause to look forward to it. They know they can win tight matches by playing positive, ball on the ground football. They know Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle will only get better - Carle must be getting close to a Socceroos recall.
And Terry Antonis, one of the A League's brightest prospects, wasn't even playing on Sunday. This could be a great season.
Monday, October 10, 2011
Back In Action
Just a quick post to my two loyal readers: I'll be at the Brisbane game and will be blogging afterwards. The draw against Melbourne was encouraging and fascinating, but it's hard to take too much from just seeing it on tv. Until Saturday...
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Emerton The Solution To Lavicka's Midfield Riddle
Brett Emerton is every manager's must-have player. Emerton is a model professional and a capable technician, and is positionally versatile and ridiculously fit (in the stamina sense - the other sense is perhaps best left to the marketing department).
But Viteslav Lavicka now has a devilish problem to resolve. Emerton is probably happiest playing as a genuine right winger, but the Czech master's preference for a midfield diamond is well known. He has shown no intention to play with wingers - in fact, he shipped off Kofi Danning, his only genuine wide man, and we know that Sydney FC were expecting to recruit Emerton next season but nabbed him 12 months early.
So how does Lavicka fit an EPL-standard winger into his starting 11, while making full use of his talents?
Emerton could play at right back. Lavicka has never settled on Shannon Cole or Seb Ryall in the troublesome spot, and the swift exit of Byun and recruitment of Jamie Coyne demonstrates his dissatisfaction with his younger options. Emerton has played right back for the Socceroos for years and would dominate opposing attackers.
But has Emerton really come to Australia to mark out a winger and mind a touchline, occasionally venturing forward in the conservative way that Lavicka has demanded of his fullbacks over the last two years? It seems doubtful, even though Emerton's decision making and enormous engine are actually perfectly suited to playing the wingback role behind a midfield diamond. It is to be hoped that the rush to push the marquee man goalwards doesn't stop Lavicka from trying Emerton at right back with Karol Kisel ahead of him.
One can however assume that Lavicka will want maximum influence from his premier player and will probably slot Emerton into a midfield role as soon as possible. One hopes he is smart enough to exploit the Socceroo's versatility. Emerton can play right back, defensive midfield, right wing or even genuine centre midfield, and he will probably fill all of these roles within a 90 minutes.
Lavicka demands that his players pass to feet along the grass. We are often told that ball on the ground football is best played by players rotating between positions. Such lofty ambitions are no longer beyond Sydney FC and there is a first 11 that would allow them to switch between formations while playing their young stars alongside their Socceroo mentors - a goal that Sydney should ignore for another year to their peril.
Here is a starting 11 within the current squad that can fluidly shift from a diamond 4-4-2 to a flat 4-4-2 and a classic 4-1-4-1. Let's start with Lavicka's preferred diamond:
-----------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Petratos----------------
---------------------Carle----------------------
-------------Antonis-----Emerton-------------
-------------------McFlynn---------------------
-Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
----------------------Reddy--------------------
Here Petratos plays the role of support striker. Note that the formation already encourages players to swap and shift between the lines. Antonis, Petratos and Carle can all play at LCM, at 10 or at support striker, while McFlynn can push on with Antonis and Emerton covering behind as both have done for the Socceroos. Emerton can also switch with Shannon Cole, though Lavicka will probably choose new recruit Jamie Coyne.
This same 11 can quickly switch to the following shape:
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Antonis/Carle----------------
Petratos-------Carle/Antonis----------McFlynn----------Emerton
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
In this flat midfield Emerton plays in his favoured right winger role and McFlynn holds the midfield fort, but others are admittedly out of their comfort zones. Petratos is left-footed and has played left wing but looks more comfortable in central roles. Here Carle can float out left to bring Petratos back into the centre, while Carle and Antonis share their preferred number 10 spot as well as the "Modric" role in the middle. A lot would be required of Scott Jamieson, a confidence player at the best of times.
Still, the formation is remarkably fluid. All four midfielders can comfortably occupy central roles, while Carle and Emerton have repeatedly played wide positions for the Socceroos. Carle, Antonis and Petratos all love to play behind Bruno at 9, and Emerton can surge forward as well.
If the team gets a lead and Lavicka plays conservatively (an approach which did take Sydney to a double just a year ago), he can switch things up without making a substitution.
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
------------Petratos-----Antonis-----Carle----------Emerton
--------------------------------McFlynn-----------------------
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
This formation can break at pace. Carle and Antonis are particularly capable of playing through balls to Emerton and Petratos, and Cazarine is particularly adept at running across two central defenders to keep them interested.
The key man in all of this is probably the captain - Terry McFlynn. In each formation he is required to do much more than break heads and bust a gut. In the diamond McFlynn's distribution would be tested and if his passing goes astray (as is known to happen), the entire formation breaks down. In the second formation, McFlynn is required to "mind" a much smaller central midfield partner. In the defensive variation McFlynn is again the chief distributor as Lavicka loathes to bypass the man in the hole.
McFlynn struggled in central defensive midfield last season, but reports suggest that Lavicka has him in mind for Stuart Musialik's old role. If he can make it work, it will instantly free up what was a battling midfield. If he can't, the captain may be benched for Rhyan Grant or Hiro Moriyasu.
This starting 11 has other weakness - Petratos plays outside his natural central midfield role, and the squad might lack height at set pieces against physical outfits. But a creative midfield core of Petratos, Antonis, Emerton and Carle is a vast improvement on Musialik, Hiro, McFlynn and Bridge, which is what Sydney was reduced to when injury and poor recruitment cruelled last year's campaign.
But Viteslav Lavicka now has a devilish problem to resolve. Emerton is probably happiest playing as a genuine right winger, but the Czech master's preference for a midfield diamond is well known. He has shown no intention to play with wingers - in fact, he shipped off Kofi Danning, his only genuine wide man, and we know that Sydney FC were expecting to recruit Emerton next season but nabbed him 12 months early.
So how does Lavicka fit an EPL-standard winger into his starting 11, while making full use of his talents?
Emerton could play at right back. Lavicka has never settled on Shannon Cole or Seb Ryall in the troublesome spot, and the swift exit of Byun and recruitment of Jamie Coyne demonstrates his dissatisfaction with his younger options. Emerton has played right back for the Socceroos for years and would dominate opposing attackers.
But has Emerton really come to Australia to mark out a winger and mind a touchline, occasionally venturing forward in the conservative way that Lavicka has demanded of his fullbacks over the last two years? It seems doubtful, even though Emerton's decision making and enormous engine are actually perfectly suited to playing the wingback role behind a midfield diamond. It is to be hoped that the rush to push the marquee man goalwards doesn't stop Lavicka from trying Emerton at right back with Karol Kisel ahead of him.
One can however assume that Lavicka will want maximum influence from his premier player and will probably slot Emerton into a midfield role as soon as possible. One hopes he is smart enough to exploit the Socceroo's versatility. Emerton can play right back, defensive midfield, right wing or even genuine centre midfield, and he will probably fill all of these roles within a 90 minutes.
Lavicka demands that his players pass to feet along the grass. We are often told that ball on the ground football is best played by players rotating between positions. Such lofty ambitions are no longer beyond Sydney FC and there is a first 11 that would allow them to switch between formations while playing their young stars alongside their Socceroo mentors - a goal that Sydney should ignore for another year to their peril.
Here is a starting 11 within the current squad that can fluidly shift from a diamond 4-4-2 to a flat 4-4-2 and a classic 4-1-4-1. Let's start with Lavicka's preferred diamond:
-----------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Petratos----------------
---------------------Carle----------------------
-------------Antonis-----Emerton-------------
-------------------McFlynn---------------------
-Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
----------------------Reddy--------------------
Here Petratos plays the role of support striker. Note that the formation already encourages players to swap and shift between the lines. Antonis, Petratos and Carle can all play at LCM, at 10 or at support striker, while McFlynn can push on with Antonis and Emerton covering behind as both have done for the Socceroos. Emerton can also switch with Shannon Cole, though Lavicka will probably choose new recruit Jamie Coyne.
This same 11 can quickly switch to the following shape:
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Antonis/Carle----------------
Petratos-------Carle/Antonis----------McFlynn----------Emerton
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
In this flat midfield Emerton plays in his favoured right winger role and McFlynn holds the midfield fort, but others are admittedly out of their comfort zones. Petratos is left-footed and has played left wing but looks more comfortable in central roles. Here Carle can float out left to bring Petratos back into the centre, while Carle and Antonis share their preferred number 10 spot as well as the "Modric" role in the middle. A lot would be required of Scott Jamieson, a confidence player at the best of times.
Still, the formation is remarkably fluid. All four midfielders can comfortably occupy central roles, while Carle and Emerton have repeatedly played wide positions for the Socceroos. Carle, Antonis and Petratos all love to play behind Bruno at 9, and Emerton can surge forward as well.
If the team gets a lead and Lavicka plays conservatively (an approach which did take Sydney to a double just a year ago), he can switch things up without making a substitution.
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
------------Petratos-----Antonis-----Carle----------Emerton
--------------------------------McFlynn-----------------------
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
This formation can break at pace. Carle and Antonis are particularly capable of playing through balls to Emerton and Petratos, and Cazarine is particularly adept at running across two central defenders to keep them interested.
The key man in all of this is probably the captain - Terry McFlynn. In each formation he is required to do much more than break heads and bust a gut. In the diamond McFlynn's distribution would be tested and if his passing goes astray (as is known to happen), the entire formation breaks down. In the second formation, McFlynn is required to "mind" a much smaller central midfield partner. In the defensive variation McFlynn is again the chief distributor as Lavicka loathes to bypass the man in the hole.
McFlynn struggled in central defensive midfield last season, but reports suggest that Lavicka has him in mind for Stuart Musialik's old role. If he can make it work, it will instantly free up what was a battling midfield. If he can't, the captain may be benched for Rhyan Grant or Hiro Moriyasu.
This starting 11 has other weakness - Petratos plays outside his natural central midfield role, and the squad might lack height at set pieces against physical outfits. But a creative midfield core of Petratos, Antonis, Emerton and Carle is a vast improvement on Musialik, Hiro, McFlynn and Bridge, which is what Sydney was reduced to when injury and poor recruitment cruelled last year's campaign.
Thursday, August 18, 2011
Mourinho: The Real Enemy of Football
Real Madrid and Barcelona are becoming dangerous. Pep Guardiola knows it. Gerard Pique knows it, though he ascribes the blame more to one side. Journalists know it - they know that violence on the pitch will have the inevitable consequence.
But Jose Mourinho lurches on, like an enraged alcoholic destroying his own hallway; gouging eyes, spitting insults, muttering conspiracies, dragging the game down to his own embittered level. He cannot yet counter Barcelona and the failure must not be his. It was the ball boys that lost a game where Barcelona enjoyed 70 percent of possession. It was the diving from Barcelona that forced him to gouge an eye, and then smirk about it.
The "Enemy of Football" enjoys little respect throughout the world game. I would guess that his only friends are the former players who he shielded from controversy, while encouraging them to give up all in the pursuit of victory. On the other side, Guardiola is no angel and in my previous post I lament the level that Pedro, Alves and others have sunk to in their mindless pursuit of victory. I am no partisan Barcelona supporter and it's clear that no players should leave the bench to pick a fight with a player on the pitch, as Barcelona did.
But if both sides do not calm down some idiot will leave a Classico, see a fan from the other side and murder them. He might not wait for the game to end. The imagination of the hooligan knows few bounds.
He'll say that he was following the example of his heroes, sticking up for his club, and that the other guy provoked him and deserved it. His behaviour will follow the same logic as Mourinho's, as Marcelo's, as Villa's, and on and on it goes.
Both sides will wring their hands. The clubs will say the killer was no "true fan", and the teams will probably show a modicum of restraint in the next match. They will wear black armbands. Then it will be back to normal.
At least Guardiola has recognised this. But Mourinho rages, attacking the ball boys, the diving Barcelona players, attacking, attacking, never acknowledging that gouging a person's eye is universally despised behaviour.
It is staggering that a proud club like Real Madrid will not sack a manager who has brought their club into disrepute. It is sad that the Spanish FA lacks the power and will to take strong action, though their history of acting for the good of the game is particularly discouraging.
It is tragically pathetic that it will probably take a death to stop this tiresome, depressing devolution of what should be the game's premier clash - a meeting of two proud clubs, of Messi and Ronaldo, of Xavi and Kaka, of sumptuous talents and tactics and trickery.
The troubling thought is that football's classic match has been so corrupted that both clubs would probably continue their death roll regardless of such a crime. After all, the pursuit of power in a world of sport is clearly more important than safety, ethics and morality. Real, Barca and the Spanish FA are shamed, whether they know it or not.
But Jose Mourinho lurches on, like an enraged alcoholic destroying his own hallway; gouging eyes, spitting insults, muttering conspiracies, dragging the game down to his own embittered level. He cannot yet counter Barcelona and the failure must not be his. It was the ball boys that lost a game where Barcelona enjoyed 70 percent of possession. It was the diving from Barcelona that forced him to gouge an eye, and then smirk about it.
The "Enemy of Football" enjoys little respect throughout the world game. I would guess that his only friends are the former players who he shielded from controversy, while encouraging them to give up all in the pursuit of victory. On the other side, Guardiola is no angel and in my previous post I lament the level that Pedro, Alves and others have sunk to in their mindless pursuit of victory. I am no partisan Barcelona supporter and it's clear that no players should leave the bench to pick a fight with a player on the pitch, as Barcelona did.
But if both sides do not calm down some idiot will leave a Classico, see a fan from the other side and murder them. He might not wait for the game to end. The imagination of the hooligan knows few bounds.
He'll say that he was following the example of his heroes, sticking up for his club, and that the other guy provoked him and deserved it. His behaviour will follow the same logic as Mourinho's, as Marcelo's, as Villa's, and on and on it goes.
Both sides will wring their hands. The clubs will say the killer was no "true fan", and the teams will probably show a modicum of restraint in the next match. They will wear black armbands. Then it will be back to normal.
At least Guardiola has recognised this. But Mourinho rages, attacking the ball boys, the diving Barcelona players, attacking, attacking, never acknowledging that gouging a person's eye is universally despised behaviour.
It is staggering that a proud club like Real Madrid will not sack a manager who has brought their club into disrepute. It is sad that the Spanish FA lacks the power and will to take strong action, though their history of acting for the good of the game is particularly discouraging.
It is tragically pathetic that it will probably take a death to stop this tiresome, depressing devolution of what should be the game's premier clash - a meeting of two proud clubs, of Messi and Ronaldo, of Xavi and Kaka, of sumptuous talents and tactics and trickery.
The troubling thought is that football's classic match has been so corrupted that both clubs would probably continue their death roll regardless of such a crime. After all, the pursuit of power in a world of sport is clearly more important than safety, ethics and morality. Real, Barca and the Spanish FA are shamed, whether they know it or not.
Saturday, July 9, 2011
Barcelona are boring because nobody likes Goliath
Wilt Chamberlain slept with twenty thousand girls and scored one hundred points in a single NBA game. 'Wilt the Stilt' was so dominant that he was booed despite his brilliance - until a young Kareem Abdul-Jabbar rose to challenge him.
Wilt genially summed up his unpopularity for the media - "No one roots for Goliath." I felt the same way watching Manchester United wilt and fall to the irrepressible Barcelona in the Champions League final.
Barcelona's brilliance has transformed football into a game more akin to basketball, water polo or European handball. A team advances with the ball via a passage of intricate but predictable play, and then shoots.
The problem is that Barcelona are so good that the game is all one way. No one can get the ball off them, and no one can hold on to it against them. A match against the Catalans swiftly becomes a succession of one-way blows. Barca's unbridled success is well deserved but the majesty of their glory is fading, mostly thanks to the histrionics of Daniel Alves and Pedro.
It's surely indisputable that Barcelona's tiki-taka has claimed Spain, Europe and the world. The Barcelona way is now the Spanish way - the World Cup was proof of that. Alex Ferguson, perhaps the world's most experienced and financially-backed manager, has attacked them twice and failed miserably. Jose Mourinho assembled the most expensive squad in the history of football and failed to do anything but degenerate the game into more of a boxing match than Holland's attack on Spain in the World Cup Final.
Barca's dominance is best demonstrated by the brilliance of their players. Few could force their way into the Barcelona First XI. One might prefer a marauding Gareth Bale over Eric Abidal, or perhaps the cool Ricardo Carvalho instead of Gerard Pique. But apart from Arjen Robben (and of course, a certain C. Ronaldo) Barcelona can claim to have the best in the world - and their spine is completely home-grown.
I would love to see Barcelona in the flesh. They play a beautiful style of football, they dive less than most and they score wonderful goals.
But the time has come for a challenger to rise against them, for a tactical innovation to re-shape the game, to restore football to a match of 90 minutes and 90 emotions where any team with the requisite mix of valour and skill can score a goal. Football's inherent drama, its fundamental strength, springs from the contest.
The Barcelona carousel is mesmerizing, without a doubt - but nobody likes Goliath. Because Goliath is a bully.
But where can the challenge come from, and would it be worse than the beautiful game it seeks to destroy?
The safest bet is that Mourinho will find a way of stacking his defense. Real Madrid might take an ugly title over another year of humiliation, and perhaps a new "catenacchio" will emerge, a kind of inverse sweeper plugging the space where Messi, Xavi and Iniesta roam. Messi's magic from the false nine position has made the two centrebacks redundant. I'm betting that Mourinho will mould a back three to ward off Pedro and Villa, and send Pepe out to man-mark Messi. The determination to avoid another 5-nil thrashing is already evident in Pepe's transformation from centre back to midfield, and Mourinho's affection for a midfield made by the destroyers Diarra, Alonso and Khedira.
Mourinho beat Barca with Inter Milan by packing the defence and relying on one or two counter-attacks over 180 minutes. How Sir Alex Ferguson re-shapes his (surely final) challenge will be fascinating, while Chelsea and Manchester City are probably the only other clubs in with a fighting chance.
I fear that next season's Champions League will be dominated by clubs playing on the counter. That's why we should all mourn the absence of Tottenham Hotspur - a club long shorn of European glory, but with the verve, ability and ambition to take on any comers. Unfortunately their chance to take a shot at Barcelona was cruelled by Peter Crouch's stupidity.
Tottenham vs Barcelona - that would have been David vs Goliath. And David might have had a chance.
Wilt genially summed up his unpopularity for the media - "No one roots for Goliath." I felt the same way watching Manchester United wilt and fall to the irrepressible Barcelona in the Champions League final.
Barcelona's brilliance has transformed football into a game more akin to basketball, water polo or European handball. A team advances with the ball via a passage of intricate but predictable play, and then shoots.
The problem is that Barcelona are so good that the game is all one way. No one can get the ball off them, and no one can hold on to it against them. A match against the Catalans swiftly becomes a succession of one-way blows. Barca's unbridled success is well deserved but the majesty of their glory is fading, mostly thanks to the histrionics of Daniel Alves and Pedro.
It's surely indisputable that Barcelona's tiki-taka has claimed Spain, Europe and the world. The Barcelona way is now the Spanish way - the World Cup was proof of that. Alex Ferguson, perhaps the world's most experienced and financially-backed manager, has attacked them twice and failed miserably. Jose Mourinho assembled the most expensive squad in the history of football and failed to do anything but degenerate the game into more of a boxing match than Holland's attack on Spain in the World Cup Final.
Barca's dominance is best demonstrated by the brilliance of their players. Few could force their way into the Barcelona First XI. One might prefer a marauding Gareth Bale over Eric Abidal, or perhaps the cool Ricardo Carvalho instead of Gerard Pique. But apart from Arjen Robben (and of course, a certain C. Ronaldo) Barcelona can claim to have the best in the world - and their spine is completely home-grown.
I would love to see Barcelona in the flesh. They play a beautiful style of football, they dive less than most and they score wonderful goals.
But the time has come for a challenger to rise against them, for a tactical innovation to re-shape the game, to restore football to a match of 90 minutes and 90 emotions where any team with the requisite mix of valour and skill can score a goal. Football's inherent drama, its fundamental strength, springs from the contest.
The Barcelona carousel is mesmerizing, without a doubt - but nobody likes Goliath. Because Goliath is a bully.
But where can the challenge come from, and would it be worse than the beautiful game it seeks to destroy?
The safest bet is that Mourinho will find a way of stacking his defense. Real Madrid might take an ugly title over another year of humiliation, and perhaps a new "catenacchio" will emerge, a kind of inverse sweeper plugging the space where Messi, Xavi and Iniesta roam. Messi's magic from the false nine position has made the two centrebacks redundant. I'm betting that Mourinho will mould a back three to ward off Pedro and Villa, and send Pepe out to man-mark Messi. The determination to avoid another 5-nil thrashing is already evident in Pepe's transformation from centre back to midfield, and Mourinho's affection for a midfield made by the destroyers Diarra, Alonso and Khedira.
Mourinho beat Barca with Inter Milan by packing the defence and relying on one or two counter-attacks over 180 minutes. How Sir Alex Ferguson re-shapes his (surely final) challenge will be fascinating, while Chelsea and Manchester City are probably the only other clubs in with a fighting chance.
I fear that next season's Champions League will be dominated by clubs playing on the counter. That's why we should all mourn the absence of Tottenham Hotspur - a club long shorn of European glory, but with the verve, ability and ambition to take on any comers. Unfortunately their chance to take a shot at Barcelona was cruelled by Peter Crouch's stupidity.
Tottenham vs Barcelona - that would have been David vs Goliath. And David might have had a chance.
Sunday, April 17, 2011
Sydney FC wasting the worst of times
Sydney FC fans were supposed to enjoy a season of promise. Instead they endure a bitter malaise. The club is locked in a suffocating spiral as a dwindling tribe of disgruntled supporters show up to sing for a stuttering and terrified squad.
How did it come to this?
The champions built on their famous double by replacing an ageing and failed marquee in John Aloisi with a fringe Socceroo and genuine number 10. A front office headed by the impeccably credentialed Edwin Lugt and bankrolled by David Traktovenko stated the ambition to become a premier club in Asia (later the "preeminent club in Asia") and coach Viteslav Lavicka looked forward to warming up for his title defence with glamour preseason friendlies against Everton, Rangers, Blackburn and AEK Athens.
Now Lugt is gone. The Festival of Football was a lonely failure. Sydney FC could not even claim the false honour of a finals place. The Asian Champions League campaign is crippled, almost certainly beyond repair. Last season's mastermind is tottering despite his recent contract extension, undermined by his one dimensional approach, limited squad and failure to recruit players who can excel within his system.
I have already chronicled how the A League campaign fell apart under the weight of poor recruitment, a cascade of injuries and the unexpected acceleration in the quality of the A League. But the ACL is another matter.
Last week Sydney FC capitulated against Kashima Antlers. The club has failed to win a home game in the ACL and departs for unfriendly shores against superior opposition. Three points in Shanghai are an absolute necessity for a side that will face up against group leaders Kashima and Suwon with no clear idea of how to beat them.
More experienced scribes than I have already written about how Sydney FC's new low standards of ambition are a disgraceful mockery of the club's potential. Michael Cockerill believes that the club must recruit a Harry Kewell-level marquee player to haul itself out of a death spiral. I agree with the need to recruit a genuine marquee striker and believe that a Yorke or Fowler level signing would bring back 5,000 fans to the first home game, possibly more. But there is a particular type of striker that is required to entice the thousands of paying members to every home game.
Sydney FC fans demand more than football. We know that the SFS will never host a technical exhibition to match what we can see at home on television. But Sydney FC's greatest problem is its lack of flair. The idea of enduring 90 minutes of Mark Bridge and Dimitri Petratos playing out of position is more than most can bear. It was equally frustrating to witness the armband pass to a player not deemed worthy of a new contract in Stuart Musialik. How can a club not have more than one leader?
Sydney need flair and belief in equal measure. They need a swashbuckling striker who will show more heart than Bridge or Bruno Cazarine, and better touch than Juho Makela. Alex Brosque was popular because he believed in his own abilities. Precious few Sky Blues do the same - Shannon Cole's enduring popularity is based on his confidence, not his defensive positioning.
Kewell would fit the bill (hopefully his contract would include a requirement that he stay on his feet and play nice with the referees). Michael Owen's Premier League appeal would also do quite nicely. Miroslav Klose and Ruud Van Nistelrooy round out the quartet of impossible targets, but this is the ambition that Sydney FC must show.
More likely marquee targets are Vince Grella or Scott Chipperfield - neither would fill the flair void that Nicky Carle cannot match on his own. Whoever replaces Lugt will have one hell of a job finding the marquee man that Sydney rightly crave.
How did it come to this?
The champions built on their famous double by replacing an ageing and failed marquee in John Aloisi with a fringe Socceroo and genuine number 10. A front office headed by the impeccably credentialed Edwin Lugt and bankrolled by David Traktovenko stated the ambition to become a premier club in Asia (later the "preeminent club in Asia") and coach Viteslav Lavicka looked forward to warming up for his title defence with glamour preseason friendlies against Everton, Rangers, Blackburn and AEK Athens.
Now Lugt is gone. The Festival of Football was a lonely failure. Sydney FC could not even claim the false honour of a finals place. The Asian Champions League campaign is crippled, almost certainly beyond repair. Last season's mastermind is tottering despite his recent contract extension, undermined by his one dimensional approach, limited squad and failure to recruit players who can excel within his system.
I have already chronicled how the A League campaign fell apart under the weight of poor recruitment, a cascade of injuries and the unexpected acceleration in the quality of the A League. But the ACL is another matter.
Last week Sydney FC capitulated against Kashima Antlers. The club has failed to win a home game in the ACL and departs for unfriendly shores against superior opposition. Three points in Shanghai are an absolute necessity for a side that will face up against group leaders Kashima and Suwon with no clear idea of how to beat them.
More experienced scribes than I have already written about how Sydney FC's new low standards of ambition are a disgraceful mockery of the club's potential. Michael Cockerill believes that the club must recruit a Harry Kewell-level marquee player to haul itself out of a death spiral. I agree with the need to recruit a genuine marquee striker and believe that a Yorke or Fowler level signing would bring back 5,000 fans to the first home game, possibly more. But there is a particular type of striker that is required to entice the thousands of paying members to every home game.
Sydney FC fans demand more than football. We know that the SFS will never host a technical exhibition to match what we can see at home on television. But Sydney FC's greatest problem is its lack of flair. The idea of enduring 90 minutes of Mark Bridge and Dimitri Petratos playing out of position is more than most can bear. It was equally frustrating to witness the armband pass to a player not deemed worthy of a new contract in Stuart Musialik. How can a club not have more than one leader?
Sydney need flair and belief in equal measure. They need a swashbuckling striker who will show more heart than Bridge or Bruno Cazarine, and better touch than Juho Makela. Alex Brosque was popular because he believed in his own abilities. Precious few Sky Blues do the same - Shannon Cole's enduring popularity is based on his confidence, not his defensive positioning.
Kewell would fit the bill (hopefully his contract would include a requirement that he stay on his feet and play nice with the referees). Michael Owen's Premier League appeal would also do quite nicely. Miroslav Klose and Ruud Van Nistelrooy round out the quartet of impossible targets, but this is the ambition that Sydney FC must show.
More likely marquee targets are Vince Grella or Scott Chipperfield - neither would fill the flair void that Nicky Carle cannot match on his own. Whoever replaces Lugt will have one hell of a job finding the marquee man that Sydney rightly crave.
Tuesday, March 8, 2011
A Wasted Summer Part 4: When 1.1 Goals Per Game Isn't Enough
Sydney FC won the last championship with a combination of clean sheets and clinical strikes. In 2010/11 the Sky Blues lost their defence and forgot how to score.
Injuries to key attackers Nick Carle and Alex Brosque and the club's decision to replace Karol Kisel with a left back crippled the front men from the start.
Add Mark Bridge's debilitating loss of form to the late recruitment of Bruno Cazarine and one quickly understands why the defending champions scored just 35 goals in 30 games.
The three goals against Melbourne in the opening game were almost as good as it got - Sydney attacked with confidence, intent and poise. And then it all went to shit, the season swallowed by what might have been.
The championship winners took the title by scoring 1.3 goals a game. But they also conceded 23 in 27, not the 40 in 30 of the "title defence". When strikers don't score or defend, as was the case with Mark Bridge and others throughout the season, any team is in dire trouble.
SQUAD REVIEW
STRIKERS
Alex Brosque, Bruno Cazarine, Juho Makela, David Williams (loan)*
Alex Brosque was Sydney's main man. A pacy, two footed and creative striker, as comfortable out wide taking on a fullback as he was flicking a pass to an onrushing midfielder, Brosque was the perfect support striker for Viteslav Lavicka's diamond midfield.
Before his acrimonious transfer abroad Brosque scored six goals in 13 starts and two appearances off the bench. His year was frustrated by niggling injuries and he tended to contribute in fits and starts, as opposed to dominating games.
Brosque was frequently Sydney's most direct player and the way he split and committed defenders immediately made space for others. Sydney will miss his mobility and, more notably, his agility. His departure has left Viteslav Lavicka with a pair of battering rams.
Bruno Cazarine was recruited after a prolonged courtship and his 9 goals in 20 starts are widely credited with saving Sydney's season. A cool finisher within the box with his head and feet, Bruno brought a direct option with a deft enough first touch, and a positional awareness often lacking from Bridge.
Big Bruno may not match the Samba template but he brought much-needed balance to a Sydney side. His obvious desire in the first half of the season lifted the club after he was finally signed in September. One imagines he could have made an even greater impact had he enjoyed a pre-season with Carle, Bridge, Brosque and company.
Bruno has re-signed for another season and his selection for the ACL shows Lavicka's faith in his ability. Cazarine can hold the ball up and choose the right option. His little and large combination with Dimitri Petratos was something to savour and it will be fascinating to see how Lavicka sends out the troops next Spring once David Williams has departed.
One hopes Bruno can work on his shooting from outside the box: a crucial option in the arsenal for less-mobile strikers, particularly in a Sydney side often guilty of over-elaboration.
Juho Makela is an interesting case. Allegedly recruited without the approval of his coach, the Shark sunk his teeth into the A League before his form petered out at the end of the season.
Lavicka tried pairing Makela with Cazarine but the two seem too similar, too comfortable leading the line and too predictable with the ball at their feet. Defending against the two was all barge and no risk and it was no real surprise when Makela was chosen to warm the pine for the ACL.
Someone should tell Sydney's webmaster, who still states that Makela's "height and size will be great attributes for Sydney FC in the 2011 AFC Champions League".
Makela has an obvious nose for goal and seems relatively effective in the air, but looks short of agility at a relatively sedate full throttle. Unless he can find a way to fit around Cazarine's style, I predict Makela will feature mostly on the bench next season as a perfectly able backup to Bruno.
Where Makela and Petratos play will be determined by David Williams. Williams has played for the Socceroos and long enjoyed the "next big thing" tag despite a rather unflattering strike rate of 12 goals in 85 career appearances.
Williams now occupies the attacking winger role but would be converted to second striker by the wing-shy Lavicka. He has what Sydney lack most of all - pace, and the ability to take defenders on in one on one situations. It seems extremely unlikely that Williams will sign a long-term deal but he would be a very welcome addition.
Sydney will most likely head into the next A League with a strike force of Cazarine and Makela as genuine number 9s, supplemented by Mark Bridge and Dimitri Petratos. A pacier option, perhaps in the form of a marquee signing, would be very welcome indeed.
*Mark Bridge, Dimitri Petratos and Kofi Danning's contributions are examined here.
Injuries to key attackers Nick Carle and Alex Brosque and the club's decision to replace Karol Kisel with a left back crippled the front men from the start.
Add Mark Bridge's debilitating loss of form to the late recruitment of Bruno Cazarine and one quickly understands why the defending champions scored just 35 goals in 30 games.
The three goals against Melbourne in the opening game were almost as good as it got - Sydney attacked with confidence, intent and poise. And then it all went to shit, the season swallowed by what might have been.
The championship winners took the title by scoring 1.3 goals a game. But they also conceded 23 in 27, not the 40 in 30 of the "title defence". When strikers don't score or defend, as was the case with Mark Bridge and others throughout the season, any team is in dire trouble.
SQUAD REVIEW
STRIKERS
Alex Brosque, Bruno Cazarine, Juho Makela, David Williams (loan)*
Alex Brosque was Sydney's main man. A pacy, two footed and creative striker, as comfortable out wide taking on a fullback as he was flicking a pass to an onrushing midfielder, Brosque was the perfect support striker for Viteslav Lavicka's diamond midfield.
Before his acrimonious transfer abroad Brosque scored six goals in 13 starts and two appearances off the bench. His year was frustrated by niggling injuries and he tended to contribute in fits and starts, as opposed to dominating games.
Brosque was frequently Sydney's most direct player and the way he split and committed defenders immediately made space for others. Sydney will miss his mobility and, more notably, his agility. His departure has left Viteslav Lavicka with a pair of battering rams.
Bruno Cazarine was recruited after a prolonged courtship and his 9 goals in 20 starts are widely credited with saving Sydney's season. A cool finisher within the box with his head and feet, Bruno brought a direct option with a deft enough first touch, and a positional awareness often lacking from Bridge.
Big Bruno may not match the Samba template but he brought much-needed balance to a Sydney side. His obvious desire in the first half of the season lifted the club after he was finally signed in September. One imagines he could have made an even greater impact had he enjoyed a pre-season with Carle, Bridge, Brosque and company.
Bruno has re-signed for another season and his selection for the ACL shows Lavicka's faith in his ability. Cazarine can hold the ball up and choose the right option. His little and large combination with Dimitri Petratos was something to savour and it will be fascinating to see how Lavicka sends out the troops next Spring once David Williams has departed.
One hopes Bruno can work on his shooting from outside the box: a crucial option in the arsenal for less-mobile strikers, particularly in a Sydney side often guilty of over-elaboration.
Juho Makela is an interesting case. Allegedly recruited without the approval of his coach, the Shark sunk his teeth into the A League before his form petered out at the end of the season.
Lavicka tried pairing Makela with Cazarine but the two seem too similar, too comfortable leading the line and too predictable with the ball at their feet. Defending against the two was all barge and no risk and it was no real surprise when Makela was chosen to warm the pine for the ACL.
Someone should tell Sydney's webmaster, who still states that Makela's "height and size will be great attributes for Sydney FC in the 2011 AFC Champions League".
Makela has an obvious nose for goal and seems relatively effective in the air, but looks short of agility at a relatively sedate full throttle. Unless he can find a way to fit around Cazarine's style, I predict Makela will feature mostly on the bench next season as a perfectly able backup to Bruno.
Where Makela and Petratos play will be determined by David Williams. Williams has played for the Socceroos and long enjoyed the "next big thing" tag despite a rather unflattering strike rate of 12 goals in 85 career appearances.
Williams now occupies the attacking winger role but would be converted to second striker by the wing-shy Lavicka. He has what Sydney lack most of all - pace, and the ability to take defenders on in one on one situations. It seems extremely unlikely that Williams will sign a long-term deal but he would be a very welcome addition.
Sydney will most likely head into the next A League with a strike force of Cazarine and Makela as genuine number 9s, supplemented by Mark Bridge and Dimitri Petratos. A pacier option, perhaps in the form of a marquee signing, would be very welcome indeed.
*Mark Bridge, Dimitri Petratos and Kofi Danning's contributions are examined here.
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
A Wasted Summer Part 3: Sydney FC's Crippled Magicians
Sydney FC's championship defence was destroyed the moment Nicky Carle succumbed to his second injury, and coach Viteslav Lavicka had only himself to blame.
The Czech oversaw a clearout of seasoned veterans but failed to replace his favourite player: Karol Kisel. The decision to fill Kisel's left midfield spot with young left back Scott Jamieson hamstrung Sydney early on, but was brutally exposed when Carle took to the sidelines.
When Steve Corica was injured last campaign, Kisel took his place at the head of Lavicka's diamond. Equally at home in the playmaking Number 10 slot or minding the left side of midfield, Kisel provided creativity and confidence on the ball.
When Nicky Carle keeled over for most of 2010, Lavicka's only options were to play Mark Bridge at 10 or promote his new signing Hiro Moriyasu, who was only just finding his feet. Bridge's catastrophic loss of form and Hiro's inability to threaten in front of goal left the team without a way to score goals or even hold up the ball and transition from defence to attack.
Lavicka's plan to shoehorn Jamieson into left midfield left the young wingback all at sea. He failed to threaten with his first touch and his delivery is too wayward to trust him with the ball at close quarters. If Lavicka had to play a fullback in midfield to accommodate Jamieson, Shannon Cole and Sung Hwan Byun, Cole would have been a much better choice.
Later injuries to Alex Brosque and Bridge sealed Sydney's fate, and the Cove only had Bruno to cheer as Sydney fizzled in front of goal.
The one positive to come from this sorry season is the emergence of Dimitri Petratos and Terry Antonis. Sydney must play these two youngsters as much as possible in 2011/2012. The A League rewards clubs that promote and develop young players, and the fans will flock to see future Socceroos learn their craft.
SQUAD REVIEW
ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS
Nick Carle, Terry Antonis, Dimitri Petratos, Kofi Danning, Brendan Gan, (Hiro Moriyasu)
Viteslav Lavicka's 4-4-2 diamond with conservative fullbacks requires creative input from the two wide midfielders. Unfortunately Lavicka chose to play Hiro Moriyasu and Terry McFlynn in front of Stuart Musialik, a conservative approach that lost Sydney games and fans.
Nicky Carle showed in the opening match against Melbourne that he can more than replace Steve Corica. Carle might lack goals and genuine pace, but his sublime touch gives Sydney the rarest of players in the A League: one who can hold up the play under pressure, play the right pass and unlock a defence with a moment of magic.
If Carle stays fit for most of the next season (and his career shows no reason to doubt he will) Sydney will make the finals. If Lavicka can play Karol Kisel or another more offensively minded player with Carle in midfield, Sydney may well go further. Sydney must attack from the first game to win back their fickle fans.
The whinging minority who call Carle a false marquee should consider the gross wages payed to John Aloisi, a player who only came good for six weeks in two years, and measure Carle's contribution at the end of his contract. Carle's wages are far from obscene and I am confident he will prove to be value for money.
News that Sydney were chasing Matt McKay showed welcome ambition and is a great relief: it means that the club has finally acknowledged the gap left by Karol Kisel in left midfield (just in time for Kisel's return). But Brisbane would never let their captain leave for free and Sydney cannot afford a transfer fee. This transfer is extremely unlikely and Sydney would be better served looking elsewhere for versatile wide midfielders: Scott Chipperfield and Brett Emerton, anyone?
Terry Antonis found precious little time on the pitch this season but Sydney must promote and develop his talent. Antonis must play, and in Carle's position, at every opportunity next year (whenever Carle is injured, suspended or tired). Antonis destroyed Wellington in February and his understanding with Dimitri Petratos in that game is surely a sign of good times to come. In that match he ran at players, picked the right pass and controlled the ball despite atrocious conditions. We can only hope he does not move overseas too early.
Dimitri Petratos is an interesting case. He has Mark Bridge's versatility but twice the ability. Petratos can pick a pass, score a goal (his air swing against the Victory aside) and occupies intelligent positions. I still believe his best position is attacking central midfielder and I hope he will find a home on the left side of midfield, but his work as Bruno Cazarine's support striker at the end of the season was inspiring. Sydney should sign him up long term and Petratos deserves to start matches.
Sadly Kofi Danning has not come on in the same way. Danning is caught in a terrible bind. His pace and enthusiasm dazzles against players his age, but his first touch can be dire and is not up to A League standard. Danning's greatest problem is his coach's system. Lavicka only plays Danning up front as a last resort and the Czech rarely plays with out and out wingers.
Now that Lavicka has re-signed with Sydney for another season, it is time for Danning to leave. Though his departure would leave Sydney short of genuine pace, the kid is at the age where he has to play. Another season on the bench will do him no favours and he does not fit within Sydney's best 20. Danning may be a likeable lad and a crowd favourite but he has not lived up to the hype.
Brendan Gan is another player who looks likely to leave. Gan should have slotted into a wide midfield role after Kisel departed, but Lavicka is clearly reluctant to pick a player who divides fans. Gan is keen and adequate, and has a cool finish, but he will probably have to leave and fight for a spot elsewhere to prove his worth.
It is a great shame that the Fury are no more. Players such as Gan and Danning could have found a home there, but will probably end up on the Gold Coast or across the Tasman instead.
MARK BRIDGE
Bridge is the only player afforded his own section throughout my season review because he is a player without a natural position. He also deserves special mention because he was undoubtedly the major disappointment of 2010/11.
This season showed Bridge to be a jack of all trades and a master of none. 1 goal and 6 assists in 19 games would be a poor return from a winger, but Bridge has played as a target man, playmaking number 10, wide midfielder and second striker.
Unfortunately he was not particularly good at any of those positions. Bridge lacks the pace to play winger, the vision and confidence to slot in at Number 10, the acceleration and lethality to excel at second striker and the sheer dynamism to lead the line.
Bridge looks most at home up front with his back to goal, and suffered badly when Nick Carle's injury forced him into attacking midfield.
Players dream of this kind of opportunity. Bridge was asked to run the offence for the A League defending champions. He tried hard but became The Cove's greatest disappointment since John Aloisi.
By late spring Bridge lacked the confidence to turn on the ball when had metres of space around him. Teams crowded him early, destroyed his confidence and reduced him to training drill passes and robotic movement off the ball. His failure to close down properly also left the team dreadfully exposed against overlapping fullbacks.
Bridge tried hard and occasionally put in a good performance. But the former Young Socceroo has suffered the curse of versatility. A sustained spell at striker produced his best form last season, but the A League has moved on. Other clubs have Van Dyk, Smeltz, Thompson and Fowler, and Sydney's "Killer Bs" though never truly prolific, could just about match that standard.
But Bridge never got near the input of the new and improved number 10s: Broich, Flores, Perez and Amini, and is certainly no Carlos Hernandez or Daniel. If the man at the top of the diamond goes into his shell, the team falls apart, and Bridge failed all too often.
It is not too late for Bridge, who clings to his new and improved contract while young talent like Matt Jurman departs for bigger money elsewhere. Like Aloisi Bridge may redeem himself and he does not lack raw ability. He needs to back himself next time he gets on the ball. He must play with the freedom denied him by the shackles of his own mind.
The Czech oversaw a clearout of seasoned veterans but failed to replace his favourite player: Karol Kisel. The decision to fill Kisel's left midfield spot with young left back Scott Jamieson hamstrung Sydney early on, but was brutally exposed when Carle took to the sidelines.
When Steve Corica was injured last campaign, Kisel took his place at the head of Lavicka's diamond. Equally at home in the playmaking Number 10 slot or minding the left side of midfield, Kisel provided creativity and confidence on the ball.
When Nicky Carle keeled over for most of 2010, Lavicka's only options were to play Mark Bridge at 10 or promote his new signing Hiro Moriyasu, who was only just finding his feet. Bridge's catastrophic loss of form and Hiro's inability to threaten in front of goal left the team without a way to score goals or even hold up the ball and transition from defence to attack.
Lavicka's plan to shoehorn Jamieson into left midfield left the young wingback all at sea. He failed to threaten with his first touch and his delivery is too wayward to trust him with the ball at close quarters. If Lavicka had to play a fullback in midfield to accommodate Jamieson, Shannon Cole and Sung Hwan Byun, Cole would have been a much better choice.
Later injuries to Alex Brosque and Bridge sealed Sydney's fate, and the Cove only had Bruno to cheer as Sydney fizzled in front of goal.
The one positive to come from this sorry season is the emergence of Dimitri Petratos and Terry Antonis. Sydney must play these two youngsters as much as possible in 2011/2012. The A League rewards clubs that promote and develop young players, and the fans will flock to see future Socceroos learn their craft.
SQUAD REVIEW
ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS
Nick Carle, Terry Antonis, Dimitri Petratos, Kofi Danning, Brendan Gan, (Hiro Moriyasu)
Viteslav Lavicka's 4-4-2 diamond with conservative fullbacks requires creative input from the two wide midfielders. Unfortunately Lavicka chose to play Hiro Moriyasu and Terry McFlynn in front of Stuart Musialik, a conservative approach that lost Sydney games and fans.
Nicky Carle showed in the opening match against Melbourne that he can more than replace Steve Corica. Carle might lack goals and genuine pace, but his sublime touch gives Sydney the rarest of players in the A League: one who can hold up the play under pressure, play the right pass and unlock a defence with a moment of magic.
If Carle stays fit for most of the next season (and his career shows no reason to doubt he will) Sydney will make the finals. If Lavicka can play Karol Kisel or another more offensively minded player with Carle in midfield, Sydney may well go further. Sydney must attack from the first game to win back their fickle fans.
The whinging minority who call Carle a false marquee should consider the gross wages payed to John Aloisi, a player who only came good for six weeks in two years, and measure Carle's contribution at the end of his contract. Carle's wages are far from obscene and I am confident he will prove to be value for money.
News that Sydney were chasing Matt McKay showed welcome ambition and is a great relief: it means that the club has finally acknowledged the gap left by Karol Kisel in left midfield (just in time for Kisel's return). But Brisbane would never let their captain leave for free and Sydney cannot afford a transfer fee. This transfer is extremely unlikely and Sydney would be better served looking elsewhere for versatile wide midfielders: Scott Chipperfield and Brett Emerton, anyone?
Terry Antonis found precious little time on the pitch this season but Sydney must promote and develop his talent. Antonis must play, and in Carle's position, at every opportunity next year (whenever Carle is injured, suspended or tired). Antonis destroyed Wellington in February and his understanding with Dimitri Petratos in that game is surely a sign of good times to come. In that match he ran at players, picked the right pass and controlled the ball despite atrocious conditions. We can only hope he does not move overseas too early.
Dimitri Petratos is an interesting case. He has Mark Bridge's versatility but twice the ability. Petratos can pick a pass, score a goal (his air swing against the Victory aside) and occupies intelligent positions. I still believe his best position is attacking central midfielder and I hope he will find a home on the left side of midfield, but his work as Bruno Cazarine's support striker at the end of the season was inspiring. Sydney should sign him up long term and Petratos deserves to start matches.
Sadly Kofi Danning has not come on in the same way. Danning is caught in a terrible bind. His pace and enthusiasm dazzles against players his age, but his first touch can be dire and is not up to A League standard. Danning's greatest problem is his coach's system. Lavicka only plays Danning up front as a last resort and the Czech rarely plays with out and out wingers.
Now that Lavicka has re-signed with Sydney for another season, it is time for Danning to leave. Though his departure would leave Sydney short of genuine pace, the kid is at the age where he has to play. Another season on the bench will do him no favours and he does not fit within Sydney's best 20. Danning may be a likeable lad and a crowd favourite but he has not lived up to the hype.
Brendan Gan is another player who looks likely to leave. Gan should have slotted into a wide midfield role after Kisel departed, but Lavicka is clearly reluctant to pick a player who divides fans. Gan is keen and adequate, and has a cool finish, but he will probably have to leave and fight for a spot elsewhere to prove his worth.
It is a great shame that the Fury are no more. Players such as Gan and Danning could have found a home there, but will probably end up on the Gold Coast or across the Tasman instead.
MARK BRIDGE
Bridge is the only player afforded his own section throughout my season review because he is a player without a natural position. He also deserves special mention because he was undoubtedly the major disappointment of 2010/11.
This season showed Bridge to be a jack of all trades and a master of none. 1 goal and 6 assists in 19 games would be a poor return from a winger, but Bridge has played as a target man, playmaking number 10, wide midfielder and second striker.
Unfortunately he was not particularly good at any of those positions. Bridge lacks the pace to play winger, the vision and confidence to slot in at Number 10, the acceleration and lethality to excel at second striker and the sheer dynamism to lead the line.
Bridge looks most at home up front with his back to goal, and suffered badly when Nick Carle's injury forced him into attacking midfield.
Players dream of this kind of opportunity. Bridge was asked to run the offence for the A League defending champions. He tried hard but became The Cove's greatest disappointment since John Aloisi.
By late spring Bridge lacked the confidence to turn on the ball when had metres of space around him. Teams crowded him early, destroyed his confidence and reduced him to training drill passes and robotic movement off the ball. His failure to close down properly also left the team dreadfully exposed against overlapping fullbacks.
Bridge tried hard and occasionally put in a good performance. But the former Young Socceroo has suffered the curse of versatility. A sustained spell at striker produced his best form last season, but the A League has moved on. Other clubs have Van Dyk, Smeltz, Thompson and Fowler, and Sydney's "Killer Bs" though never truly prolific, could just about match that standard.
But Bridge never got near the input of the new and improved number 10s: Broich, Flores, Perez and Amini, and is certainly no Carlos Hernandez or Daniel. If the man at the top of the diamond goes into his shell, the team falls apart, and Bridge failed all too often.
It is not too late for Bridge, who clings to his new and improved contract while young talent like Matt Jurman departs for bigger money elsewhere. Like Aloisi Bridge may redeem himself and he does not lack raw ability. He needs to back himself next time he gets on the ball. He must play with the freedom denied him by the shackles of his own mind.
Monday, February 28, 2011
A Wasted Summer Part 2: Sydney FC's defensive midfield
Sydney FC scored 29 goals in 30 games this season. The defending champions won the previous title by scoring then shutting teams out, but Sydney forgot how to score this time around and conceded 40 goals.
Sydney's precipitous drop in form was felt across the park and part one of my review examined the club's defenders and goalkeepers. It is now time to examine the men at the coalface - and how they let down their teammates and fans.
SQUAD REVIEW
DEFENSIVE MIDFIELDERS
Stuart Musialik, Terry McFlynn, Hirofumi Moriyasu, Rhyan Grant
Stuart Musialik arrived in Sydney as a fringe Socceroo and an improving young player - a technically adroit defensive midfielder as composed on the ball as he was efficient off it. Musialik revelled in his favourite "sit and distribute" role last season as Lavicka sat him behind Steve Corica, Karol Kisel and the robust Terry McFlynn.
But Musialik has endured a poor 2010/11. After the opening match against Melbourne, I wrote "Musialik put in his usual performance: an excellent, controlling game apart from one or two dreadful errors that put his team under pressure". Unfortunately Musialik's moments of excellence dimmed until the New Year, and he lost his confidence on the ball just as Viteslav Lavicka lost confidence in his contribution. Musialik - a main man in the championship winning team - remains out of contract for next season. I would miss his best but not mourn his passing, and it would not surprise many to see him suiting up next to Jason Culina for the Jets next summer.
Skipper Terry McFlynn has been underwhelming ever since his superb chip agonizingly found the wrong side of the underside of the bar against the North Queensland Fury. That 1-1 draw in the September rain crippled Sydney's finals campaign and sucked the morale out of the club and the crowd. For McFlynn to finally produce a moment of skill but miss by centimetres from far outside the box was crushing.
McFlynn has offered precious little on the ball and while the skipper's return from injury certainly steadied the ship after Sydney's first few matches, the improvement in A League midfields may have made McFlynn obsolete - at least as a wide midfielder. One goal and one assist in 27 games tells a partial but compelling story and regular readers of this column (I appreciate all two of you!) will know I am not a great fan of what McFlynn brings to the team (his wonderful clearance off the line against the Glory aside).
The future for Sydney is a little brighter. Rhyan Grant enjoyed a strong tournament for the Young Socceroos and looked comfortable enough when filling in for an out-of-form Stuart Musialik. He could seize the position at the base of Sydney's diamond with a strong pre-season, particularly if Musialik leaves as expected. While he is dynamic enough when played wider, he offered few moments of creativity or threat on the ball to suggest he is anything but a defensive midfielder.
New signing Hiro Moriyasu is an interesting case. Hiro played without the fear that seemed to afflict Sydney after Nicky Carle succumbed to injury and his dynamism in midfield was a big reason that the Sky Blues shook themselves back to life. He tackles decisively and backs himself technically - sometimes to his detriment, particularly against fast-pressing teams such as Brisbane.
Hiro has found his home on either side of the midfield diamond and contributes as a box-to-box hard-running midfielder, who can also play a pass (such as the assist for Alex Brosque at Parramatta Stadium). His limitations are clear: he scored one goal from 38 attempts this season and freezes when running at goal with the ball at his feet.
If Hiro can improve his shooting and dribbling options then Sydney will boast a competent trio of screeners and box-to-box players next season. If Stuart Musialik stays in Sydney then Grant may suffer without game time. But will Lavicka gamble on an inexperienced player in such a vital decision-making position? Time will tell.
One thing is clear. Grant, McFlynn, Musialik and Moriyasu provided just four goals all season. Sydney can only afford to have two of the three in the team. The more defensively minded midfielders must be complemented by an attacking player like Karol Kisel or Dimitri Petratos. Left back Scott Jamieson's presence in left midfield at the start of the season shackled an already low scoring side.
And finally: defensive midfield may be the side's engine room, but Sydney need more from their skipper. Will McFlynn keep the armband?
Sydney's precipitous drop in form was felt across the park and part one of my review examined the club's defenders and goalkeepers. It is now time to examine the men at the coalface - and how they let down their teammates and fans.
SQUAD REVIEW
DEFENSIVE MIDFIELDERS
Stuart Musialik, Terry McFlynn, Hirofumi Moriyasu, Rhyan Grant
Stuart Musialik arrived in Sydney as a fringe Socceroo and an improving young player - a technically adroit defensive midfielder as composed on the ball as he was efficient off it. Musialik revelled in his favourite "sit and distribute" role last season as Lavicka sat him behind Steve Corica, Karol Kisel and the robust Terry McFlynn.
But Musialik has endured a poor 2010/11. After the opening match against Melbourne, I wrote "Musialik put in his usual performance: an excellent, controlling game apart from one or two dreadful errors that put his team under pressure". Unfortunately Musialik's moments of excellence dimmed until the New Year, and he lost his confidence on the ball just as Viteslav Lavicka lost confidence in his contribution. Musialik - a main man in the championship winning team - remains out of contract for next season. I would miss his best but not mourn his passing, and it would not surprise many to see him suiting up next to Jason Culina for the Jets next summer.
Skipper Terry McFlynn has been underwhelming ever since his superb chip agonizingly found the wrong side of the underside of the bar against the North Queensland Fury. That 1-1 draw in the September rain crippled Sydney's finals campaign and sucked the morale out of the club and the crowd. For McFlynn to finally produce a moment of skill but miss by centimetres from far outside the box was crushing.
McFlynn has offered precious little on the ball and while the skipper's return from injury certainly steadied the ship after Sydney's first few matches, the improvement in A League midfields may have made McFlynn obsolete - at least as a wide midfielder. One goal and one assist in 27 games tells a partial but compelling story and regular readers of this column (I appreciate all two of you!) will know I am not a great fan of what McFlynn brings to the team (his wonderful clearance off the line against the Glory aside).
The future for Sydney is a little brighter. Rhyan Grant enjoyed a strong tournament for the Young Socceroos and looked comfortable enough when filling in for an out-of-form Stuart Musialik. He could seize the position at the base of Sydney's diamond with a strong pre-season, particularly if Musialik leaves as expected. While he is dynamic enough when played wider, he offered few moments of creativity or threat on the ball to suggest he is anything but a defensive midfielder.
New signing Hiro Moriyasu is an interesting case. Hiro played without the fear that seemed to afflict Sydney after Nicky Carle succumbed to injury and his dynamism in midfield was a big reason that the Sky Blues shook themselves back to life. He tackles decisively and backs himself technically - sometimes to his detriment, particularly against fast-pressing teams such as Brisbane.
Hiro has found his home on either side of the midfield diamond and contributes as a box-to-box hard-running midfielder, who can also play a pass (such as the assist for Alex Brosque at Parramatta Stadium). His limitations are clear: he scored one goal from 38 attempts this season and freezes when running at goal with the ball at his feet.
If Hiro can improve his shooting and dribbling options then Sydney will boast a competent trio of screeners and box-to-box players next season. If Stuart Musialik stays in Sydney then Grant may suffer without game time. But will Lavicka gamble on an inexperienced player in such a vital decision-making position? Time will tell.
One thing is clear. Grant, McFlynn, Musialik and Moriyasu provided just four goals all season. Sydney can only afford to have two of the three in the team. The more defensively minded midfielders must be complemented by an attacking player like Karol Kisel or Dimitri Petratos. Left back Scott Jamieson's presence in left midfield at the start of the season shackled an already low scoring side.
And finally: defensive midfield may be the side's engine room, but Sydney need more from their skipper. Will McFlynn keep the armband?
Monday, February 21, 2011
2010-2011: A Wasted Summer Part 1
A near 30 percent drop in average crowds. No finals football. The acrimonious loss of their Socceroo and star striker.
It wasn't the worst of times but the best of times faded pretty quickly this season for Sydney FC.
The A League has few real traditions but a swift stab in the back for under-performing Sydney managers is a seasonal delight. Viteslav Lavicka is very, very lucky to still be in a job. The Sydney FC overlords are to be commended for their restraint and thanked for their deep pockets.
Few others associated with the club deserve the same sentiment. Sydney is a city of high expectations (and lamentably low levels of supporter loyalty). For A League champions to miss the finals is not unprecedented but remains catastrophic. It is time to take stock.
The Asian Champions League can do more than salve the wounds from this campaign. It is time for the club to be decisive. It needs to jettison or play Stuart Musialik, Sung Hwan Byun and Stephan Keller. Lavicka needs to nurture or release Kofi Danning and find the best positions for Shannon Cole and Seb Ryall. He must pick and stick with one of Liam Reddy and Ivan Necevski.
Indecision has robbed Sydney FC of Matt Jurman - Lavicka should not be permitted to put his own short-term priorities ahead of future development. Lavicka's fight for survival is the bed that the board has made until the spring. Sydney will just have to live with it.
SQUAD REVIEW
GOALKEEPERS
Liam Reddy, Ivan Necevski
Australian football seems best at generating goalkeepers and to have a mediocre keeper is unacceptable. Reddy and Necevski were frustratingly inconsistent throughout this season and while both bore the cost of shaky shifts put in by those in front of them, neither seized the position with anything like the determination and confidence displayed so often by Clint Bolton. Reddy was very poor at times, particularly against North Queensland when he failed to read the obvious intentions of David Williams, while Necevski seems unable to grasp a cross or corner.
The decision to release Bolton, recruit Reddy and retain Necevski looks dodgy, particularly given the need for stability at the back with the obvious departure of Simon Colosimo (who was contemplating a trip overseas for months). It may have been a question of timing and wages, but there are better keepers home and abroad. Would it be too rude to mention Danny Vukovic?
CENTRAL DEFENCE
Hayden Foxe, Stephan Keller, Seb Ryall, Matt Jurman, Antony Golec, Andrew Durante (loan)
The source of many of Sydney's woes. The decision to replace the ball-playing Simon Colosimo with the skilled but slow-footed Hayden Foxe put Lavicka in a constant tactical bind. A central pairing of Foxe and Stephan Keller was extremely vulnerable to the pacy attacks of early season foes. Last season's high line and compact defence evaporated early. Too often the last line was left too deep to intercept but too high to recover, and Seb Ryall's inconsistencies and weakness in the air cost him his place - somewhat unfairly, in my opinion, as some of Keller's displays were particularly dire. Matt Jurman's emergence as a talented compromise candidate came too late to save Sydney's season and his departure is one to mourn.
The centrebacks were not assisted by unusually poor form from the screening Stuart Musialik and the ball holding target man Mark Bridge, but the end of the Asian Champions League campaign will bring a real challenge to the Sky Blue backline. Odds are that Keller, Foxe, Jurman and Durante will all depart, leaving Ryall and Golec, who barely played at all this season, as the only specialist centrebacks for the next A League season. Sydney will plummet from over supply to a chronic shortage in an area where they seemed so well stocked just 18 months ago.
Of course we all expect the club to sign a new central defender soon but outstanding candidates are thin on the ground. Jade North is another undersized centreback who can be maddeningly inconsistent - a Ryall/North partnership would be vulnerable to tall, rough attacks and the players' own panic attacks on and off the ball. Sydney need to find a more permanent solution than Durante - a signing I applaud, but a stopgap measure none the less. Jamie Coyne is a long way from Simon Colosimo's level of ability, even taking into account Colosimo's poor season in Melbourne.
For a club to play two central defenders that are on their way out, or not even Sydney players to begin with, is more than a symptom of poor recruitment - it is counter productive in the long run.
FULL BACKS
Shannon Cole, Sung Hwan Byun, Scott Jamieson, (Seb Ryall)
Full back might be Sydney's strongest area going into Asia - an odd assertion given that Byun could be trimmed to make room for other foreigners and Ryall will rarely start matches at rightback.
In Shannon Cole and Scott Jamieson Sydney have a pair of fullbacks at home in the tackle, dogged over 90 minutes and happy to bomb forward with the ball at their feet.
Both have their limitations. Cole's attitude and ability in attack is sabotaged by some poor positioning and tendency to ball watch, while Jamieson's first touch and delivery from wide areas can be phenomenally dire. Jamieson is also rather one-footed and loses speed at the end of the second half.
But Lavicka's set up of a conservative midfield three behind a hard-running number 10 requires attack-minded fullbacks and there are few better suited to the task, or with more potential for improvement, than Cole and Jamieson (not that Josh Rose, Cassio or Shane Steffanuto are not slightly above the Sydney two).
If Sydney can settle on a midfield anchorman, a centreback combination and keep Nick Carle fit, Cole and Jamieson will find form and consistency. It was not easy for Cole to half-heartedly get forward as the ball was lost in midfield, or for Jamieson to start off as a left midfielder (a position he should never play again).
Ryall is too conservative a fullback for an already narrow team and Lavicka seems rightly unlikely to play him on the right unless the last 10 minutes require locking up. Byun will always be a Sydney hero but his second season will be remembered for yelling at his teammates and shrugging his shoulders.
The recruitment of a seasoned left back such as Dean Heffernan would simply retard Jamieson's progress in the same way that Cassio's brilliance forced him out of Adelaide. Sydney should find another solution, perhaps a left footed centreback who provides a defensive alternative, and continue to develop their two Australians. The whispered arrival of Scott Chipperfield could also work, provided Chipperfield plays in midfield and provides cover for injury.
It wasn't the worst of times but the best of times faded pretty quickly this season for Sydney FC.
The A League has few real traditions but a swift stab in the back for under-performing Sydney managers is a seasonal delight. Viteslav Lavicka is very, very lucky to still be in a job. The Sydney FC overlords are to be commended for their restraint and thanked for their deep pockets.
Few others associated with the club deserve the same sentiment. Sydney is a city of high expectations (and lamentably low levels of supporter loyalty). For A League champions to miss the finals is not unprecedented but remains catastrophic. It is time to take stock.
The Asian Champions League can do more than salve the wounds from this campaign. It is time for the club to be decisive. It needs to jettison or play Stuart Musialik, Sung Hwan Byun and Stephan Keller. Lavicka needs to nurture or release Kofi Danning and find the best positions for Shannon Cole and Seb Ryall. He must pick and stick with one of Liam Reddy and Ivan Necevski.
Indecision has robbed Sydney FC of Matt Jurman - Lavicka should not be permitted to put his own short-term priorities ahead of future development. Lavicka's fight for survival is the bed that the board has made until the spring. Sydney will just have to live with it.
SQUAD REVIEW
GOALKEEPERS
Liam Reddy, Ivan Necevski
Australian football seems best at generating goalkeepers and to have a mediocre keeper is unacceptable. Reddy and Necevski were frustratingly inconsistent throughout this season and while both bore the cost of shaky shifts put in by those in front of them, neither seized the position with anything like the determination and confidence displayed so often by Clint Bolton. Reddy was very poor at times, particularly against North Queensland when he failed to read the obvious intentions of David Williams, while Necevski seems unable to grasp a cross or corner.
The decision to release Bolton, recruit Reddy and retain Necevski looks dodgy, particularly given the need for stability at the back with the obvious departure of Simon Colosimo (who was contemplating a trip overseas for months). It may have been a question of timing and wages, but there are better keepers home and abroad. Would it be too rude to mention Danny Vukovic?
CENTRAL DEFENCE
Hayden Foxe, Stephan Keller, Seb Ryall, Matt Jurman, Antony Golec, Andrew Durante (loan)
The source of many of Sydney's woes. The decision to replace the ball-playing Simon Colosimo with the skilled but slow-footed Hayden Foxe put Lavicka in a constant tactical bind. A central pairing of Foxe and Stephan Keller was extremely vulnerable to the pacy attacks of early season foes. Last season's high line and compact defence evaporated early. Too often the last line was left too deep to intercept but too high to recover, and Seb Ryall's inconsistencies and weakness in the air cost him his place - somewhat unfairly, in my opinion, as some of Keller's displays were particularly dire. Matt Jurman's emergence as a talented compromise candidate came too late to save Sydney's season and his departure is one to mourn.
The centrebacks were not assisted by unusually poor form from the screening Stuart Musialik and the ball holding target man Mark Bridge, but the end of the Asian Champions League campaign will bring a real challenge to the Sky Blue backline. Odds are that Keller, Foxe, Jurman and Durante will all depart, leaving Ryall and Golec, who barely played at all this season, as the only specialist centrebacks for the next A League season. Sydney will plummet from over supply to a chronic shortage in an area where they seemed so well stocked just 18 months ago.
Of course we all expect the club to sign a new central defender soon but outstanding candidates are thin on the ground. Jade North is another undersized centreback who can be maddeningly inconsistent - a Ryall/North partnership would be vulnerable to tall, rough attacks and the players' own panic attacks on and off the ball. Sydney need to find a more permanent solution than Durante - a signing I applaud, but a stopgap measure none the less. Jamie Coyne is a long way from Simon Colosimo's level of ability, even taking into account Colosimo's poor season in Melbourne.
For a club to play two central defenders that are on their way out, or not even Sydney players to begin with, is more than a symptom of poor recruitment - it is counter productive in the long run.
FULL BACKS
Shannon Cole, Sung Hwan Byun, Scott Jamieson, (Seb Ryall)
Full back might be Sydney's strongest area going into Asia - an odd assertion given that Byun could be trimmed to make room for other foreigners and Ryall will rarely start matches at rightback.
In Shannon Cole and Scott Jamieson Sydney have a pair of fullbacks at home in the tackle, dogged over 90 minutes and happy to bomb forward with the ball at their feet.
Both have their limitations. Cole's attitude and ability in attack is sabotaged by some poor positioning and tendency to ball watch, while Jamieson's first touch and delivery from wide areas can be phenomenally dire. Jamieson is also rather one-footed and loses speed at the end of the second half.
But Lavicka's set up of a conservative midfield three behind a hard-running number 10 requires attack-minded fullbacks and there are few better suited to the task, or with more potential for improvement, than Cole and Jamieson (not that Josh Rose, Cassio or Shane Steffanuto are not slightly above the Sydney two).
If Sydney can settle on a midfield anchorman, a centreback combination and keep Nick Carle fit, Cole and Jamieson will find form and consistency. It was not easy for Cole to half-heartedly get forward as the ball was lost in midfield, or for Jamieson to start off as a left midfielder (a position he should never play again).
Ryall is too conservative a fullback for an already narrow team and Lavicka seems rightly unlikely to play him on the right unless the last 10 minutes require locking up. Byun will always be a Sydney hero but his second season will be remembered for yelling at his teammates and shrugging his shoulders.
The recruitment of a seasoned left back such as Dean Heffernan would simply retard Jamieson's progress in the same way that Cassio's brilliance forced him out of Adelaide. Sydney should find another solution, perhaps a left footed centreback who provides a defensive alternative, and continue to develop their two Australians. The whispered arrival of Scott Chipperfield could also work, provided Chipperfield plays in midfield and provides cover for injury.
Saturday, January 15, 2011
Game 25 - Sydney FC 1 vs Melbourne Victory 1 - 15/01/11
Melbourne had three of the five clear cut chances in this enthralling match but Sydney should have dominated a contest so full of hope and despair that Juho Makela's equalizing goal was, for a good two seconds after it hit the net, too good to be believed by half the crowd.
Sydney raced back to the halfway line ball in hand and buoyed by stunned supporters, somehow believing that after failing to score for 91 minutes, they could thrash one into the net in 90 seconds. Too little, too late for Viteslav Lavicka, who will be lucky to survive the week.
Finals football was a forlorn hope after the devastating draw with the Fury back in October's three-game stretch. Last night's failure has cut the cord. Sydney are six points back and have played two more games than the sixth-placed Jets.
The case against Sydney FC is simple. If you can't beat your biggest rivals when they are missing four of their best five outfield players, when you are playing in front of your biggest home crowd, when you have 16 shots at goal in the first half, then you don't deserve to play in the finals.
At halftime I wrote: "The game has the feel of a Sydney FC training run with everyone missing their shots. I fear a sucker punch."
If Juho Makela was fit to start, the Sky Blues would have won the match. If Alex Brosque was fit to play it would have been a rout. If Hiro Moriyasu's shot had slid inside the post, if Dimitri Petratos had even touched the ball...
A title defence should not depend on wishes or sentiment. Sydney have drawn or lost 19 out of 25 games this season. That the Sky Blues have a mathematical chance of finals football is an insult to other sides.
Judging by last night's glorious first half what hurts the most is what might have been. Sydney flew at Melbourne unburdened by the doubts that have crippled this campaign. Melbourne had the two best chances of the half but it seemed a moot point, such was Sydney's dominance.
The first 45 minutes were encapsulated by one Sydney movement when Nicky Carle rode a challenge then back-heeled the ball to kick off a raid that ended in a shot off target. Carle dominated the first half in the same way that he dominated the opening game of the season. How Sydney have suffered under the poor form of Mark Bridge.
Melbourne were desperate to slow the game down but still had the best chances of the first 45. Stephan Keller inexplicably decided to let a sliding cross roll past him along the six yard box and straight onto Danny Allsopp's boot, and Liam Reddy was lucky to see a feeble header spring from Matt Jurman's last-ditch challenge on Allsopp, whose movement troubled Sydney's back two all night.
By the 35th minute some Sydney players were getting restless. Bruno Cazarine put in more petulance than workrate and Juho Makela's drifting runs were a welcome addition after he came on for Hiro Moriyasu at the 55th minute. If Alex Brosque returns, Big Bruno will be lucky to keep his place. Stephan Keller's 80th minute shot from near the centre circle was selfish, stupid and hardly the thing to invigorate his supporters or his side. Skipper Terry McFlynn should not be allowing this sort of thing.
Nicky Carle deserved his man of the match award but his detractors (and there are many) will quite rightly point out that he failed to place a shot on target and that his cross to Makela may well have been a mis-cued shot. He was also peripheral in the first fifteen minutes of the second half when Sydney's passing was comical at best and atrocious at worst. McFlynn and Bruno, then Byun and Makela made pathetic efforts to attack down the right hand side and Carle should have demanded the ball to restore Sydney's possession.
All that said, Carle played in Petratos for what should have been a certain goal, put the ball right onto Makela's foot for his strike and tore Melbourne to shreds in the first 45. Things are looking up for what will be a very tough Asian Champions League campaign.
18-year-old Dimitri Petratos has played in four different positions: across midfield and as a support striker. He ran himself into the ground last night but looks most at home with players in front of him. The air swing was poor and but hopefully his confidence is shored up strong foundations. Does Viteslav Lavicka have the wherewithal to slot Petratos back into midfield before he has too much time to dwell on his miss? Time will tell.
Which brings us to the boss himself. If the Sydney board show the ruthlessness of their predecessors then this failure - and it is a failure - should be Czechmate for Lavicka.
It depends on the players. If they have lost all confidence in Lavicka then he should be congratulated for last season and retired. The first half performance does not indicate that things have degenerated that far. But Lavicka seems unable to improve the team at halftime which is when a manager should be at his best.
Few managers have enjoyed this much patience from a board. Lavicka has recruited the wrong replacements for the wrong departures, has stuck with the the wrong tactics at the wrong times and failed to shore up the confidence of a previously dominant and swaggering team.
One more game without a win should seal his departure. If the looming "mid-January" board meeting comes before Sunday's game against the high-flying Mariner, Lavicka may not get even that chance.
EDIT: One thing I forgot to mention was the fantastic contribution from The Cove. They were in amazing form with another brilliant tifo, and here's hoping everyone comes back for the final game of the season against the Phoenix next month. If you missed it, here's a link I snagged from parkingthebus on Twitter.
Sydney raced back to the halfway line ball in hand and buoyed by stunned supporters, somehow believing that after failing to score for 91 minutes, they could thrash one into the net in 90 seconds. Too little, too late for Viteslav Lavicka, who will be lucky to survive the week.
Finals football was a forlorn hope after the devastating draw with the Fury back in October's three-game stretch. Last night's failure has cut the cord. Sydney are six points back and have played two more games than the sixth-placed Jets.
The case against Sydney FC is simple. If you can't beat your biggest rivals when they are missing four of their best five outfield players, when you are playing in front of your biggest home crowd, when you have 16 shots at goal in the first half, then you don't deserve to play in the finals.
At halftime I wrote: "The game has the feel of a Sydney FC training run with everyone missing their shots. I fear a sucker punch."
If Juho Makela was fit to start, the Sky Blues would have won the match. If Alex Brosque was fit to play it would have been a rout. If Hiro Moriyasu's shot had slid inside the post, if Dimitri Petratos had even touched the ball...
A title defence should not depend on wishes or sentiment. Sydney have drawn or lost 19 out of 25 games this season. That the Sky Blues have a mathematical chance of finals football is an insult to other sides.
Judging by last night's glorious first half what hurts the most is what might have been. Sydney flew at Melbourne unburdened by the doubts that have crippled this campaign. Melbourne had the two best chances of the half but it seemed a moot point, such was Sydney's dominance.
The first 45 minutes were encapsulated by one Sydney movement when Nicky Carle rode a challenge then back-heeled the ball to kick off a raid that ended in a shot off target. Carle dominated the first half in the same way that he dominated the opening game of the season. How Sydney have suffered under the poor form of Mark Bridge.
Melbourne were desperate to slow the game down but still had the best chances of the first 45. Stephan Keller inexplicably decided to let a sliding cross roll past him along the six yard box and straight onto Danny Allsopp's boot, and Liam Reddy was lucky to see a feeble header spring from Matt Jurman's last-ditch challenge on Allsopp, whose movement troubled Sydney's back two all night.
By the 35th minute some Sydney players were getting restless. Bruno Cazarine put in more petulance than workrate and Juho Makela's drifting runs were a welcome addition after he came on for Hiro Moriyasu at the 55th minute. If Alex Brosque returns, Big Bruno will be lucky to keep his place. Stephan Keller's 80th minute shot from near the centre circle was selfish, stupid and hardly the thing to invigorate his supporters or his side. Skipper Terry McFlynn should not be allowing this sort of thing.
Nicky Carle deserved his man of the match award but his detractors (and there are many) will quite rightly point out that he failed to place a shot on target and that his cross to Makela may well have been a mis-cued shot. He was also peripheral in the first fifteen minutes of the second half when Sydney's passing was comical at best and atrocious at worst. McFlynn and Bruno, then Byun and Makela made pathetic efforts to attack down the right hand side and Carle should have demanded the ball to restore Sydney's possession.
All that said, Carle played in Petratos for what should have been a certain goal, put the ball right onto Makela's foot for his strike and tore Melbourne to shreds in the first 45. Things are looking up for what will be a very tough Asian Champions League campaign.
18-year-old Dimitri Petratos has played in four different positions: across midfield and as a support striker. He ran himself into the ground last night but looks most at home with players in front of him. The air swing was poor and but hopefully his confidence is shored up strong foundations. Does Viteslav Lavicka have the wherewithal to slot Petratos back into midfield before he has too much time to dwell on his miss? Time will tell.
Which brings us to the boss himself. If the Sydney board show the ruthlessness of their predecessors then this failure - and it is a failure - should be Czechmate for Lavicka.
It depends on the players. If they have lost all confidence in Lavicka then he should be congratulated for last season and retired. The first half performance does not indicate that things have degenerated that far. But Lavicka seems unable to improve the team at halftime which is when a manager should be at his best.
Few managers have enjoyed this much patience from a board. Lavicka has recruited the wrong replacements for the wrong departures, has stuck with the the wrong tactics at the wrong times and failed to shore up the confidence of a previously dominant and swaggering team.
One more game without a win should seal his departure. If the looming "mid-January" board meeting comes before Sunday's game against the high-flying Mariner, Lavicka may not get even that chance.
EDIT: One thing I forgot to mention was the fantastic contribution from The Cove. They were in amazing form with another brilliant tifo, and here's hoping everyone comes back for the final game of the season against the Phoenix next month. If you missed it, here's a link I snagged from parkingthebus on Twitter.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)