Adelaide United hit the post twice and Ivan Necevski made six superb saves to secure Sydney FC three precious points on Sunday night.
It is a mark of Sydney's schizophrenic season that they could secure 65 percent of possession in the first half yet safely be described as undeserving winners. In the first 45 minutes Sydney enjoyed the ball without displaying real ruthlessness, until the previously-ineffective Joel Chianese caressed a difficult volley in from a corner.
The goal released all the pressure on Sydney FC and they came out after halftime determined to land a killer blow - yet Adelaide surged back and finished as the far stronger side. In the first half the South Australians closed down like Australian manufacturing, but in the second half they suffocated Sydney's creaky transition play.
Adelaide hit the post twice and while Eugene Galekovic made one save, clear man of the match Ivan Necevski made six and watched the ball smash against the upright.
Barbiero butchered a fantastic opporturnity, Cassio hit the post, Caravella drew the best out of Necevski from point-blank range and both managers acknowledged who Lady Luck favoured on Sunday night.
Sydney FC might sneak into the finals and will fancy themselves to do some damage. But they must be concerned after a dominant first half display with 65 percent of possession required a ricochet opening from a set piece.
A squad stacked with Socceroos in attacking positions should do better at fashioning opportunities (and congratulations to Brett Emerton and especially Nicky Carle for their well-deserved call ups for Wednesday night).
Wellington Phoenix are tougher prey and Viteslav Lavicka will have to weigh a number of issues.
The back five are sorted: Scott Jamieson put in an impressive attacking shift on Sunday and delivered the decisive through ball to Mitch Mallia after shrugging off a nasty head knock. Ivan Necevski keeps his place while Rhyan Grant continues his crash course at right back.
As ever, Sydney's front six are the paradox. Hiro Moriyasu put in a solid performance without expressing any real influence on the match. In fairness, Hiro is not a proper left winger and his best work comes in the middle of the park.
If Karol Kisel is fit to start, Moriyasu will probably drop to the bench despite Kisel's own dislike for the left side and Moriyasu's solid return to the starting line up (Terry Antonis should be given time in the youth league to reach proper match fitness for what will be a string of must-win games).
Goal scorer Joel Chianese will no doubt enjoy the opposite experience to Hiro: Chianese's strike will probably secure him another start, but the youngster stumbled over several other opportunities to shoot, cross or even trap and clearly remains a work in progress.
Chianese's scoring volley was sumptuously taken, but fundamental slips, such as failing to win a corner when trapped on the touchline, or not finding a yard to deliver a cross to Bruno (Chianese would be wise to study Cassio in this regard) will be more costly against an in-form Wellington.
In the end Chianese's game flattered and deceived. He often found dangerous positions but failed to make good decisions or execute them under pressure - except for a lovely goal. Obviously these elements of his game can be improved with time, but Sydney need to win to make the finals.
Chianese and Mallia both have potential but need to keep improving to keep Olyroos Dimitri Petratos and Terry Antonis out of the side when they return.
Sydney FC have every reason to beat Wellington Phoenix and every chance with the strong squad at Viteslav Lavicka's disposal. A win against the high-flying Phoenix could propel Sydney into outside chances for a grand final.
A loss would further dishearten those Sydney fans already dizzy from inconsistency and disappointed by defeat. Bring on the weekend.
Showing posts with label Nicky Carle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nicky Carle. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
Monday, February 13, 2012
McFlynn out for Forgotten Hiro?
"Dignity" and "honour" were the words of last week after Sydney hit rock bottom against Newcastle. Sydney faced the A League's form side last Sunday and wrestled out a 2-1 victory against Perth that provides some of the path ahead.
Sydney were far from dominant at home - in the first half the Sky Blues were barely seen; Bruno Cazarine provided the only attacking thrust. But certain signs were encouraging: Sydney were a little more desperate, a little more alert, a little more willing in the challenge and pacy with the pass.
Brett Emerton and Scott Jamieson led the effort while Karol Kisel, Hiro Moriyasu and Bruno Cazarine played their roles. Captain Terry McFlynn was absent yet Sydney roused themselves after a fairly diabolical first half to secure three precious points.
It was Hiro, Bruno and Kisel who made Sydney's first goal - Hiro showed great awareness to combine a tackle with a touch on, Bruno perfectly released Kisel and the Slovak scampered down his least favoured left side while Joel Chianese led the defence to the near post.
The highlights show the rest: Emerton's emphatic finish, the deliberate celebration in front of The Cove, and Sydney were off to the races.
Sydney found further joy down the flanks through Jamieson and Shannon Cole before Emerton showed wonderful judgement to curl a lofted ball around a defender on the goal line and on to the brave Bruno's bullet header.
Naturally a clean sheet was too much to ask, and Sydney's inability to keep the ball in the final stages provided a needlessly nail-biting finale as Perth surged forward.
Terry McFlynn will be available for selection against Adelaide and now the dilemma presents itself: will Lavicka restore his captain to a victorious side? Hiro Moriyasu has barely played for Sydney since signing an extended contract last season, but he was incisive and decisive against Perth.
Hiro has his limitations and some touches out of trouble seemed a little speculative, but Moriyasu made the most of his opportunity and does not deserve to be dropped.
The obvious move would be to ditch home debutant Joel Chianese, who looked willing but limited as a second striker, and move Carle forward, leaving a midfield of Kisel, McFlynn, Moriyasu and Emerton.
But Nicky Carle has repeated his statement that he prefers playing at 8 over 10 and Carle has always looked better with players in front of him. Unfortunately a central midfield of Carle and Moriyasu is hardly going to help in the mix or at set pieces and when Dario Vidosic starts sending freekicks at Adelaide's smorgasbord of big men, Sydney might rue their diminutive midfield.
Lavicka's alternatives are to play Mitch Mallia next to Bruno Cazarine in a classic little/large predator/target man pairing, and slot McFlynn next Carle; or to drop McFlynn to the bench.
Lavicka has run out of reasons to pick anything but a team that matches his footballing philosophy. The outgoing manager will probably push Carle forward behind Bruno and hope that Sydney's new-found width continues to threaten. Mitch Mallia, Rhyan Grant and Carle might need to wait for next year to get a go at their preferred positions.
The rest of the side picks itself: Bruno, Emerton and Kisel will start, while Rhyan Grant and the Beauchamp/Bosschaart central pairing are chiseled into the backline.
Scott Jamieson had a brain fade against the Newcastle Jets but he seems to have dodged the usual bullet for abandoning his post. The former Next Big Thing has shown glimpses of class this season and was a constant threat on Saturday.
Shannon Cole looked lively against Perth but will remain on the bench as the great struggle for a contract continues. It is hard to believe that Sydney could cut loose a local boy and fan favourite who can cover four positions and once earned selection for the Socceroos, but Cole might be running out of chances to win a new contract.
Earlier this season Sydney FC honoured William Doggadog Duran, a fan I never met but who was clearly loved within The Cove and respected by the players. Barely a month later, less than ten thousand Sydneysiders showed up for Saturday night's game. Those who stayed missed the dignified performance they've been praying for.
If Sydney beat Adelaide, who ended their own wretched run of form with a scrappy win over Gold Coast on the weekend, the fans should return for a pivotal clash against the high-flying Wellington Phoenix on February 25.
Sydney were far from dominant at home - in the first half the Sky Blues were barely seen; Bruno Cazarine provided the only attacking thrust. But certain signs were encouraging: Sydney were a little more desperate, a little more alert, a little more willing in the challenge and pacy with the pass.
Brett Emerton and Scott Jamieson led the effort while Karol Kisel, Hiro Moriyasu and Bruno Cazarine played their roles. Captain Terry McFlynn was absent yet Sydney roused themselves after a fairly diabolical first half to secure three precious points.
It was Hiro, Bruno and Kisel who made Sydney's first goal - Hiro showed great awareness to combine a tackle with a touch on, Bruno perfectly released Kisel and the Slovak scampered down his least favoured left side while Joel Chianese led the defence to the near post.
The highlights show the rest: Emerton's emphatic finish, the deliberate celebration in front of The Cove, and Sydney were off to the races.
Sydney found further joy down the flanks through Jamieson and Shannon Cole before Emerton showed wonderful judgement to curl a lofted ball around a defender on the goal line and on to the brave Bruno's bullet header.
Naturally a clean sheet was too much to ask, and Sydney's inability to keep the ball in the final stages provided a needlessly nail-biting finale as Perth surged forward.
Terry McFlynn will be available for selection against Adelaide and now the dilemma presents itself: will Lavicka restore his captain to a victorious side? Hiro Moriyasu has barely played for Sydney since signing an extended contract last season, but he was incisive and decisive against Perth.
Hiro has his limitations and some touches out of trouble seemed a little speculative, but Moriyasu made the most of his opportunity and does not deserve to be dropped.
The obvious move would be to ditch home debutant Joel Chianese, who looked willing but limited as a second striker, and move Carle forward, leaving a midfield of Kisel, McFlynn, Moriyasu and Emerton.
But Nicky Carle has repeated his statement that he prefers playing at 8 over 10 and Carle has always looked better with players in front of him. Unfortunately a central midfield of Carle and Moriyasu is hardly going to help in the mix or at set pieces and when Dario Vidosic starts sending freekicks at Adelaide's smorgasbord of big men, Sydney might rue their diminutive midfield.
Lavicka's alternatives are to play Mitch Mallia next to Bruno Cazarine in a classic little/large predator/target man pairing, and slot McFlynn next Carle; or to drop McFlynn to the bench.
Lavicka has run out of reasons to pick anything but a team that matches his footballing philosophy. The outgoing manager will probably push Carle forward behind Bruno and hope that Sydney's new-found width continues to threaten. Mitch Mallia, Rhyan Grant and Carle might need to wait for next year to get a go at their preferred positions.
The rest of the side picks itself: Bruno, Emerton and Kisel will start, while Rhyan Grant and the Beauchamp/Bosschaart central pairing are chiseled into the backline.
Scott Jamieson had a brain fade against the Newcastle Jets but he seems to have dodged the usual bullet for abandoning his post. The former Next Big Thing has shown glimpses of class this season and was a constant threat on Saturday.
Shannon Cole looked lively against Perth but will remain on the bench as the great struggle for a contract continues. It is hard to believe that Sydney could cut loose a local boy and fan favourite who can cover four positions and once earned selection for the Socceroos, but Cole might be running out of chances to win a new contract.
Earlier this season Sydney FC honoured William Doggadog Duran, a fan I never met but who was clearly loved within The Cove and respected by the players. Barely a month later, less than ten thousand Sydneysiders showed up for Saturday night's game. Those who stayed missed the dignified performance they've been praying for.
If Sydney beat Adelaide, who ended their own wretched run of form with a scrappy win over Gold Coast on the weekend, the fans should return for a pivotal clash against the high-flying Wellington Phoenix on February 25.
Wednesday, December 7, 2011
Sydney beat the best and hope is born
It has taken this long to collect my thoughts on Sydney's remarkable bludgeoning of Brisbane on the weekend. October seems an age ago. Perhaps Viteslav Lavicka has rediscovered his side's spine.
Ground level seats by a corner post prevented me really seeing how the game unfolded (plus a Homebake hangover that endangered the cleanliness of said corner post), but certain things were obvious. After the shock of the early goal, Sydney closed down with coordinated intent. Their clear game plan was invigorated by Petratos' drive and the side shifted to each flank as one.
Brisbane only had Plan A and Sydney made a mockery of it. Safe possession was ceded to the Roar centrebacks but the fullbacks were sharked and the midfield shackled. Sydney forced the match into a 30 yard square and dared the Roar to stitch a passing path through them. Brisbane utterly failed to do so.
Sydney's "long ball" game was aided by strong gusts that pulled the Sky Blues' long passes back towards them. Bruno Cazarine won a fair share of headers while Dimi Petratos harried, hassled and won an unbelievable number of knock downs and 50/50s. Sydney sucked in the Brisbane midfield and then played the ball first time to space.
Once Sydney established their lead and willingness to gamble for scraps, they began to put their foot on the ball. Pascal Bosschaart, Shannon Cole, Karol Kisel, Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle were able to relieve the pressure of Brisbane possession, while Terry McFlynn and Jamie Coyne played their part.
Liam Reddy is a man transformed. The intense keeper has built a platform of form and confidence from his strong opening match against the Victory and orders the side around like a tyrant. In front of him Michael Beauchamp and Pascal Bosschaart played the match Sydney fans have been waiting to see. They resisted Brisbane's attempts to pull them apart and some of Bosschaart's distribution bordered on the ridiculous and/or miraculous. Can the Cove finally forget Simon Colosimo?
Shannon Cole slotted in for the suspended Scott Jamieson and the left footer might be hard-pressed to win his spot back. Cole grew into the game and his swashbuckling forays in the second half caught the eye while some in the crowd caught their breath. One little run that led to a freekick was particularly risky but Cole looked immaculate in defence and his kamikaze block must make him undroppable.
It would be harsh to drop Jamie Coyne, who did little wrong and lends much needed height at set pieces, but Cole offers courage, technique and panache. If he does get left on the bench, expect to see him on at halftime if Sydney are chasing the game.
Terry McFlynn led the side like never before. He lifted the crowd, mostly kept the ball safe and constantly encouraged the troops to left. When Petratos butchered a chance to play Bruno in, McFlynn talked the justifiably petulant Brazilian into pulling his head in. The A League has grown past the notion of McFlynn as an attacking midfielder, but he might be the anchorman to guide Sydney to glory.
I couldn't see too much of the midfield duel but all pundits seem to have praised how disciplined Sydney's most experienced players were. Carle, Emerton and Kisel are the type to relish taking on Australia's best and they will want to push the club forward.
Dimi Petratos was waiting for a chance to impress, and boy did he take it. It was an enormous shame that he couldn't take more - Petratos is not quite the predator we would wish him to be, but suddenly Sydney look strong across the front. Petratos' touch and turn make him more of a scheming midfielder than a beat-the-line speedster, but it is clear he has intrigued Lavicka and invigorated Bruno.
Mark Bridge and Terry Antonis will rightly find it hard to win a starting spot. Potential must be matched by performance in a team of Sydney's ambition.
Sydney have options all across the park, are relatively injury free and know they can beat the best team in Australian professional sporting history.
Brisbane were well below their best but Sydney won't care. They won, won with style, won the fans and know they can win a title. It is the leaders that will decide whether they build towards glory.
Sunday's success has led some to ask whether Sydney FC should move to Kogarah. The answer is in the title. Sydney is the city's football club and must play near its central station. A cozy suburb with a community stadium is a fantastic place to visit, but until someone builds Sydney's answer to AAMI Park at Redfern, the SFS is home.
Ground level seats by a corner post prevented me really seeing how the game unfolded (plus a Homebake hangover that endangered the cleanliness of said corner post), but certain things were obvious. After the shock of the early goal, Sydney closed down with coordinated intent. Their clear game plan was invigorated by Petratos' drive and the side shifted to each flank as one.
Brisbane only had Plan A and Sydney made a mockery of it. Safe possession was ceded to the Roar centrebacks but the fullbacks were sharked and the midfield shackled. Sydney forced the match into a 30 yard square and dared the Roar to stitch a passing path through them. Brisbane utterly failed to do so.
Sydney's "long ball" game was aided by strong gusts that pulled the Sky Blues' long passes back towards them. Bruno Cazarine won a fair share of headers while Dimi Petratos harried, hassled and won an unbelievable number of knock downs and 50/50s. Sydney sucked in the Brisbane midfield and then played the ball first time to space.
Once Sydney established their lead and willingness to gamble for scraps, they began to put their foot on the ball. Pascal Bosschaart, Shannon Cole, Karol Kisel, Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle were able to relieve the pressure of Brisbane possession, while Terry McFlynn and Jamie Coyne played their part.
Liam Reddy is a man transformed. The intense keeper has built a platform of form and confidence from his strong opening match against the Victory and orders the side around like a tyrant. In front of him Michael Beauchamp and Pascal Bosschaart played the match Sydney fans have been waiting to see. They resisted Brisbane's attempts to pull them apart and some of Bosschaart's distribution bordered on the ridiculous and/or miraculous. Can the Cove finally forget Simon Colosimo?
Shannon Cole slotted in for the suspended Scott Jamieson and the left footer might be hard-pressed to win his spot back. Cole grew into the game and his swashbuckling forays in the second half caught the eye while some in the crowd caught their breath. One little run that led to a freekick was particularly risky but Cole looked immaculate in defence and his kamikaze block must make him undroppable.
It would be harsh to drop Jamie Coyne, who did little wrong and lends much needed height at set pieces, but Cole offers courage, technique and panache. If he does get left on the bench, expect to see him on at halftime if Sydney are chasing the game.
Terry McFlynn led the side like never before. He lifted the crowd, mostly kept the ball safe and constantly encouraged the troops to left. When Petratos butchered a chance to play Bruno in, McFlynn talked the justifiably petulant Brazilian into pulling his head in. The A League has grown past the notion of McFlynn as an attacking midfielder, but he might be the anchorman to guide Sydney to glory.
I couldn't see too much of the midfield duel but all pundits seem to have praised how disciplined Sydney's most experienced players were. Carle, Emerton and Kisel are the type to relish taking on Australia's best and they will want to push the club forward.
Dimi Petratos was waiting for a chance to impress, and boy did he take it. It was an enormous shame that he couldn't take more - Petratos is not quite the predator we would wish him to be, but suddenly Sydney look strong across the front. Petratos' touch and turn make him more of a scheming midfielder than a beat-the-line speedster, but it is clear he has intrigued Lavicka and invigorated Bruno.
Mark Bridge and Terry Antonis will rightly find it hard to win a starting spot. Potential must be matched by performance in a team of Sydney's ambition.
Sydney have options all across the park, are relatively injury free and know they can beat the best team in Australian professional sporting history.
Brisbane were well below their best but Sydney won't care. They won, won with style, won the fans and know they can win a title. It is the leaders that will decide whether they build towards glory.
Sunday's success has led some to ask whether Sydney FC should move to Kogarah. The answer is in the title. Sydney is the city's football club and must play near its central station. A cozy suburb with a community stadium is a fantastic place to visit, but until someone builds Sydney's answer to AAMI Park at Redfern, the SFS is home.
Saturday, November 19, 2011
Mariners Rattle and Roll Over Sydney
Sydney FC's Socceroo-laden side was out-muscled, then out-hustled, and finally out-played on Saturday night. Central Coast were good value for their 3-2 win and Sydney FC must ponder some hard questions if they are to challenge for the title that "Football's Capital" surely deserves.
When Terry McFlynn left the field, perhaps succumbing to injury, perhaps to a tactical decision by Viteslav Lavicka, promising 17-year-old Terry Antonis was left to mind Daniel McBreen and a fierce Mariners outfit. Graham Arnold's side allowed Sydney a measure of harmless possession, then sharked at Mark Bridge whenever he received the ball at his feet.
The Mariners' winning goals were born from textbook transition play and when Arnold subbed McBreen for the wily Musti Amini a tiring Antonis was overwhelmed and eventually hooked. The youngster may have been overworked after Young Socceroos duties. Maybe he just had a shocker. Neither explanation should be surprising at Antonis' age, but Hiro Moriyasu might have been brought on earlier to stem the tide.
Antonis was far from Sydney's worst on a fairly forgettable night. Star marquee Brett Emerton endured a pretty average first half and was unable to shrug off Central Coast's disciplined defensive pattern. Like Antonis, Emerton should improve after a week's rest.
Michael Beauchamp was schooled by Matt Simon. Beauchamp was once selected for the Socceroos for his strength in the air and immovability on the ground. He was unable to win a header in the second half and his list of errors is starting to lengthen. Seb Ryall might start to fancy his chances of a recall at centre back, though that would leave a short Sydney team even more susceptible at set pieces.
Chris Coyne and Terry McFlynn did the dirty work, but Coyne did not take strong options with the ball at his feet and some of the passing from Sydney's "water carriers" was woeful. McFlynn was missed in the second half, particularly when the second goal was clipped in from the spot while Antonis was nowhere to be seen. Sydney will hope their captain can recover quickly - he provides the muscle that an A League competitor seems to need.
Mark Bridge seems to pop up in all the right places and then butcher all the best chances. He has never scored prolifically and is as likely to balloon a simple chance before playing an exquisite pass. Bridge failed at 10 last year and is, so far, failing at no 9. Bruno Cazarine is a man of slow feet and heavy touch but backs himself to score. Bridge fits better with Sydney's aspirations of play, but Bruno has scored 10 goals in 28 games. Bridge has 27 in 116.
Liam Reddy and Scott Jamieson built on their strong campaigns so far. Nicky Carle continues to impress but still seems more comfortable when he has more than one passing option in front of him. How to fit Carle, Emerton, Kisel, McFlynn and Antonis into a midfield diamond remains Lavicka's biggest dilemma. Right now he has decided to play his two marquee men out of position. Such a decision could be described as "courageous".
When Terry McFlynn left the field, perhaps succumbing to injury, perhaps to a tactical decision by Viteslav Lavicka, promising 17-year-old Terry Antonis was left to mind Daniel McBreen and a fierce Mariners outfit. Graham Arnold's side allowed Sydney a measure of harmless possession, then sharked at Mark Bridge whenever he received the ball at his feet.
The Mariners' winning goals were born from textbook transition play and when Arnold subbed McBreen for the wily Musti Amini a tiring Antonis was overwhelmed and eventually hooked. The youngster may have been overworked after Young Socceroos duties. Maybe he just had a shocker. Neither explanation should be surprising at Antonis' age, but Hiro Moriyasu might have been brought on earlier to stem the tide.
Antonis was far from Sydney's worst on a fairly forgettable night. Star marquee Brett Emerton endured a pretty average first half and was unable to shrug off Central Coast's disciplined defensive pattern. Like Antonis, Emerton should improve after a week's rest.
Michael Beauchamp was schooled by Matt Simon. Beauchamp was once selected for the Socceroos for his strength in the air and immovability on the ground. He was unable to win a header in the second half and his list of errors is starting to lengthen. Seb Ryall might start to fancy his chances of a recall at centre back, though that would leave a short Sydney team even more susceptible at set pieces.
Chris Coyne and Terry McFlynn did the dirty work, but Coyne did not take strong options with the ball at his feet and some of the passing from Sydney's "water carriers" was woeful. McFlynn was missed in the second half, particularly when the second goal was clipped in from the spot while Antonis was nowhere to be seen. Sydney will hope their captain can recover quickly - he provides the muscle that an A League competitor seems to need.
Mark Bridge seems to pop up in all the right places and then butcher all the best chances. He has never scored prolifically and is as likely to balloon a simple chance before playing an exquisite pass. Bridge failed at 10 last year and is, so far, failing at no 9. Bruno Cazarine is a man of slow feet and heavy touch but backs himself to score. Bridge fits better with Sydney's aspirations of play, but Bruno has scored 10 goals in 28 games. Bridge has 27 in 116.
Liam Reddy and Scott Jamieson built on their strong campaigns so far. Nicky Carle continues to impress but still seems more comfortable when he has more than one passing option in front of him. How to fit Carle, Emerton, Kisel, McFlynn and Antonis into a midfield diamond remains Lavicka's biggest dilemma. Right now he has decided to play his two marquee men out of position. Such a decision could be described as "courageous".
Monday, November 7, 2011
Kisel The Key Man
I missed the first half of Sydney FC's best game of the year thanks to a weekend stint in gaol. We arrived five minutes before halftime. The crowd was as I feared - restless, angry and smaller than it should be.
Sydneysiders sense their team's collective lack of belief. Last season the club scrapped and grappled for draws, in stark contrast to the team of two years ago who scored first and strangled teams into submission.
Viteslav Lavicka - surely the manager with the most to prove this season - identified the problem of a lack of leadership and re-recruited Karol Kisel before the close of a lost season. He beefed up Sydney's spine with Pascal Bosschaart and Michael Beauchamp, and the shock signing of Brett Emerton left Lavicka with as good a squad on paper as one could ask for: three Socceroos, three Young Socceroos, two former internationals and a host of home-grown footballers with lots to prove.
The opening arm wrestle against Melbourne was rich with promise - Sydney dominated much of the play until Mark Bridge's brain snap. The home fans endured a spanking from the Roar, but results against Adelaide and the Heart were encouraging.
What a shame it was that only 11 051 fans turned up on a gloomy Sunday afternoon to see Sydney wilt, straighten and run over Gold Coast United. It was the performance that proved Lavicka's point: he has more leaders. He can let the team off the leash because their capacity to entertain springs from mental strength.
I've previously called for Karol Kisel to be benched for Dimi Petratos and Terry Antonis. Kisel showed on Sunday exactly why he was the first player Lavicka wanted for this season. Kisel possesses belief, technique, nous and a competitive fire that spreads throughout the side.
It was Kisel, Carle and Emerton that forced Sydney FC back into the match after the calamitous second Gold Coast goal. They kicked the club into fifth gear. Passes previously delivered at a pedestrian pace skidded off the turf. Fullbacks were thrust forward while Terry McFlynn mopped up with venom.
I had figured that Kisel's inclusion would damage Sydney by forcing the messiah himself, Brett Emerton, out onto the left - a role which proved difficult against the Victory and the Roar. But Emerton proved his worth to Sydney on Sunday. His backheels, lay offs, flicks and driving runs inside and outside Gold Coast's defence pulled defenders away from Scott Jamieson, who has lifted his game this season. Perhaps Jamieson has been energized by some of the leadership that Lavicka was after. More could come from a raw, young talent.
The backline of Coyne, Bosschaart, Beauchamp and Jamieson seems settled but work is clearly required - Gold Coast's second goal would not have been out of place in an early edition of FIFA. United's forward movement often threatened to pinch a third goal - can a triangle of McFlynn, Bosschaart and Beauchamp keep up with a mobile threat?
Sydney's midfield is certainly mobile enough and technically adroit. Emerton, Nicky Carle, Karol Kisel and Terry McFlynn will take some replacing - though it was interesting that Lavicka did not decide to replace McFlynn with Rhyan Grant as the clock wore down. Instead Beauchamp galloped forward and won the crucial penalty after Gold Coast wrapped their legs around him.
Lavicka's biggest dilemma remains how to get the most out of Mark Bridge. The eternal enigma could have scored a hat trick and won a penalty, but took home nothing but the rage of the crowd after he blinked when Emerton bounced a cross towards his hip.
Some say that Bridge is the club's best natural finisher. It's time he proved it. With Bruno and Petratos nipping at his heels, to say nothing of the phantom Surgeon, Bridge will have to start taking opportunities.
Sydney's next home game is against their closest rivals - Central Coast, another side with a lot to prove. It will be a heated match but Sydney have the most cause to look forward to it. They know they can win tight matches by playing positive, ball on the ground football. They know Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle will only get better - Carle must be getting close to a Socceroos recall.
And Terry Antonis, one of the A League's brightest prospects, wasn't even playing on Sunday. This could be a great season.
Sydneysiders sense their team's collective lack of belief. Last season the club scrapped and grappled for draws, in stark contrast to the team of two years ago who scored first and strangled teams into submission.
Viteslav Lavicka - surely the manager with the most to prove this season - identified the problem of a lack of leadership and re-recruited Karol Kisel before the close of a lost season. He beefed up Sydney's spine with Pascal Bosschaart and Michael Beauchamp, and the shock signing of Brett Emerton left Lavicka with as good a squad on paper as one could ask for: three Socceroos, three Young Socceroos, two former internationals and a host of home-grown footballers with lots to prove.
The opening arm wrestle against Melbourne was rich with promise - Sydney dominated much of the play until Mark Bridge's brain snap. The home fans endured a spanking from the Roar, but results against Adelaide and the Heart were encouraging.
What a shame it was that only 11 051 fans turned up on a gloomy Sunday afternoon to see Sydney wilt, straighten and run over Gold Coast United. It was the performance that proved Lavicka's point: he has more leaders. He can let the team off the leash because their capacity to entertain springs from mental strength.
I've previously called for Karol Kisel to be benched for Dimi Petratos and Terry Antonis. Kisel showed on Sunday exactly why he was the first player Lavicka wanted for this season. Kisel possesses belief, technique, nous and a competitive fire that spreads throughout the side.
It was Kisel, Carle and Emerton that forced Sydney FC back into the match after the calamitous second Gold Coast goal. They kicked the club into fifth gear. Passes previously delivered at a pedestrian pace skidded off the turf. Fullbacks were thrust forward while Terry McFlynn mopped up with venom.
I had figured that Kisel's inclusion would damage Sydney by forcing the messiah himself, Brett Emerton, out onto the left - a role which proved difficult against the Victory and the Roar. But Emerton proved his worth to Sydney on Sunday. His backheels, lay offs, flicks and driving runs inside and outside Gold Coast's defence pulled defenders away from Scott Jamieson, who has lifted his game this season. Perhaps Jamieson has been energized by some of the leadership that Lavicka was after. More could come from a raw, young talent.
The backline of Coyne, Bosschaart, Beauchamp and Jamieson seems settled but work is clearly required - Gold Coast's second goal would not have been out of place in an early edition of FIFA. United's forward movement often threatened to pinch a third goal - can a triangle of McFlynn, Bosschaart and Beauchamp keep up with a mobile threat?
Sydney's midfield is certainly mobile enough and technically adroit. Emerton, Nicky Carle, Karol Kisel and Terry McFlynn will take some replacing - though it was interesting that Lavicka did not decide to replace McFlynn with Rhyan Grant as the clock wore down. Instead Beauchamp galloped forward and won the crucial penalty after Gold Coast wrapped their legs around him.
Lavicka's biggest dilemma remains how to get the most out of Mark Bridge. The eternal enigma could have scored a hat trick and won a penalty, but took home nothing but the rage of the crowd after he blinked when Emerton bounced a cross towards his hip.
Some say that Bridge is the club's best natural finisher. It's time he proved it. With Bruno and Petratos nipping at his heels, to say nothing of the phantom Surgeon, Bridge will have to start taking opportunities.
Sydney's next home game is against their closest rivals - Central Coast, another side with a lot to prove. It will be a heated match but Sydney have the most cause to look forward to it. They know they can win tight matches by playing positive, ball on the ground football. They know Brett Emerton and Nicky Carle will only get better - Carle must be getting close to a Socceroos recall.
And Terry Antonis, one of the A League's brightest prospects, wasn't even playing on Sunday. This could be a great season.
Thursday, August 25, 2011
Emerton The Solution To Lavicka's Midfield Riddle
Brett Emerton is every manager's must-have player. Emerton is a model professional and a capable technician, and is positionally versatile and ridiculously fit (in the stamina sense - the other sense is perhaps best left to the marketing department).
But Viteslav Lavicka now has a devilish problem to resolve. Emerton is probably happiest playing as a genuine right winger, but the Czech master's preference for a midfield diamond is well known. He has shown no intention to play with wingers - in fact, he shipped off Kofi Danning, his only genuine wide man, and we know that Sydney FC were expecting to recruit Emerton next season but nabbed him 12 months early.
So how does Lavicka fit an EPL-standard winger into his starting 11, while making full use of his talents?
Emerton could play at right back. Lavicka has never settled on Shannon Cole or Seb Ryall in the troublesome spot, and the swift exit of Byun and recruitment of Jamie Coyne demonstrates his dissatisfaction with his younger options. Emerton has played right back for the Socceroos for years and would dominate opposing attackers.
But has Emerton really come to Australia to mark out a winger and mind a touchline, occasionally venturing forward in the conservative way that Lavicka has demanded of his fullbacks over the last two years? It seems doubtful, even though Emerton's decision making and enormous engine are actually perfectly suited to playing the wingback role behind a midfield diamond. It is to be hoped that the rush to push the marquee man goalwards doesn't stop Lavicka from trying Emerton at right back with Karol Kisel ahead of him.
One can however assume that Lavicka will want maximum influence from his premier player and will probably slot Emerton into a midfield role as soon as possible. One hopes he is smart enough to exploit the Socceroo's versatility. Emerton can play right back, defensive midfield, right wing or even genuine centre midfield, and he will probably fill all of these roles within a 90 minutes.
Lavicka demands that his players pass to feet along the grass. We are often told that ball on the ground football is best played by players rotating between positions. Such lofty ambitions are no longer beyond Sydney FC and there is a first 11 that would allow them to switch between formations while playing their young stars alongside their Socceroo mentors - a goal that Sydney should ignore for another year to their peril.
Here is a starting 11 within the current squad that can fluidly shift from a diamond 4-4-2 to a flat 4-4-2 and a classic 4-1-4-1. Let's start with Lavicka's preferred diamond:
-----------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Petratos----------------
---------------------Carle----------------------
-------------Antonis-----Emerton-------------
-------------------McFlynn---------------------
-Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
----------------------Reddy--------------------
Here Petratos plays the role of support striker. Note that the formation already encourages players to swap and shift between the lines. Antonis, Petratos and Carle can all play at LCM, at 10 or at support striker, while McFlynn can push on with Antonis and Emerton covering behind as both have done for the Socceroos. Emerton can also switch with Shannon Cole, though Lavicka will probably choose new recruit Jamie Coyne.
This same 11 can quickly switch to the following shape:
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Antonis/Carle----------------
Petratos-------Carle/Antonis----------McFlynn----------Emerton
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
In this flat midfield Emerton plays in his favoured right winger role and McFlynn holds the midfield fort, but others are admittedly out of their comfort zones. Petratos is left-footed and has played left wing but looks more comfortable in central roles. Here Carle can float out left to bring Petratos back into the centre, while Carle and Antonis share their preferred number 10 spot as well as the "Modric" role in the middle. A lot would be required of Scott Jamieson, a confidence player at the best of times.
Still, the formation is remarkably fluid. All four midfielders can comfortably occupy central roles, while Carle and Emerton have repeatedly played wide positions for the Socceroos. Carle, Antonis and Petratos all love to play behind Bruno at 9, and Emerton can surge forward as well.
If the team gets a lead and Lavicka plays conservatively (an approach which did take Sydney to a double just a year ago), he can switch things up without making a substitution.
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
------------Petratos-----Antonis-----Carle----------Emerton
--------------------------------McFlynn-----------------------
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
This formation can break at pace. Carle and Antonis are particularly capable of playing through balls to Emerton and Petratos, and Cazarine is particularly adept at running across two central defenders to keep them interested.
The key man in all of this is probably the captain - Terry McFlynn. In each formation he is required to do much more than break heads and bust a gut. In the diamond McFlynn's distribution would be tested and if his passing goes astray (as is known to happen), the entire formation breaks down. In the second formation, McFlynn is required to "mind" a much smaller central midfield partner. In the defensive variation McFlynn is again the chief distributor as Lavicka loathes to bypass the man in the hole.
McFlynn struggled in central defensive midfield last season, but reports suggest that Lavicka has him in mind for Stuart Musialik's old role. If he can make it work, it will instantly free up what was a battling midfield. If he can't, the captain may be benched for Rhyan Grant or Hiro Moriyasu.
This starting 11 has other weakness - Petratos plays outside his natural central midfield role, and the squad might lack height at set pieces against physical outfits. But a creative midfield core of Petratos, Antonis, Emerton and Carle is a vast improvement on Musialik, Hiro, McFlynn and Bridge, which is what Sydney was reduced to when injury and poor recruitment cruelled last year's campaign.
But Viteslav Lavicka now has a devilish problem to resolve. Emerton is probably happiest playing as a genuine right winger, but the Czech master's preference for a midfield diamond is well known. He has shown no intention to play with wingers - in fact, he shipped off Kofi Danning, his only genuine wide man, and we know that Sydney FC were expecting to recruit Emerton next season but nabbed him 12 months early.
So how does Lavicka fit an EPL-standard winger into his starting 11, while making full use of his talents?
Emerton could play at right back. Lavicka has never settled on Shannon Cole or Seb Ryall in the troublesome spot, and the swift exit of Byun and recruitment of Jamie Coyne demonstrates his dissatisfaction with his younger options. Emerton has played right back for the Socceroos for years and would dominate opposing attackers.
But has Emerton really come to Australia to mark out a winger and mind a touchline, occasionally venturing forward in the conservative way that Lavicka has demanded of his fullbacks over the last two years? It seems doubtful, even though Emerton's decision making and enormous engine are actually perfectly suited to playing the wingback role behind a midfield diamond. It is to be hoped that the rush to push the marquee man goalwards doesn't stop Lavicka from trying Emerton at right back with Karol Kisel ahead of him.
One can however assume that Lavicka will want maximum influence from his premier player and will probably slot Emerton into a midfield role as soon as possible. One hopes he is smart enough to exploit the Socceroo's versatility. Emerton can play right back, defensive midfield, right wing or even genuine centre midfield, and he will probably fill all of these roles within a 90 minutes.
Lavicka demands that his players pass to feet along the grass. We are often told that ball on the ground football is best played by players rotating between positions. Such lofty ambitions are no longer beyond Sydney FC and there is a first 11 that would allow them to switch between formations while playing their young stars alongside their Socceroo mentors - a goal that Sydney should ignore for another year to their peril.
Here is a starting 11 within the current squad that can fluidly shift from a diamond 4-4-2 to a flat 4-4-2 and a classic 4-1-4-1. Let's start with Lavicka's preferred diamond:
-----------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Petratos----------------
---------------------Carle----------------------
-------------Antonis-----Emerton-------------
-------------------McFlynn---------------------
-Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
----------------------Reddy--------------------
Here Petratos plays the role of support striker. Note that the formation already encourages players to swap and shift between the lines. Antonis, Petratos and Carle can all play at LCM, at 10 or at support striker, while McFlynn can push on with Antonis and Emerton covering behind as both have done for the Socceroos. Emerton can also switch with Shannon Cole, though Lavicka will probably choose new recruit Jamie Coyne.
This same 11 can quickly switch to the following shape:
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
-------------------------Antonis/Carle----------------
Petratos-------Carle/Antonis----------McFlynn----------Emerton
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
In this flat midfield Emerton plays in his favoured right winger role and McFlynn holds the midfield fort, but others are admittedly out of their comfort zones. Petratos is left-footed and has played left wing but looks more comfortable in central roles. Here Carle can float out left to bring Petratos back into the centre, while Carle and Antonis share their preferred number 10 spot as well as the "Modric" role in the middle. A lot would be required of Scott Jamieson, a confidence player at the best of times.
Still, the formation is remarkably fluid. All four midfielders can comfortably occupy central roles, while Carle and Emerton have repeatedly played wide positions for the Socceroos. Carle, Antonis and Petratos all love to play behind Bruno at 9, and Emerton can surge forward as well.
If the team gets a lead and Lavicka plays conservatively (an approach which did take Sydney to a double just a year ago), he can switch things up without making a substitution.
-----------------------------Cazarine-------------------------
------------Petratos-----Antonis-----Carle----------Emerton
--------------------------------McFlynn-----------------------
---------Jamieson--Beauchamp--Bosschart--Cole/Coyne
-------------------------------Reddy--------------------
This formation can break at pace. Carle and Antonis are particularly capable of playing through balls to Emerton and Petratos, and Cazarine is particularly adept at running across two central defenders to keep them interested.
The key man in all of this is probably the captain - Terry McFlynn. In each formation he is required to do much more than break heads and bust a gut. In the diamond McFlynn's distribution would be tested and if his passing goes astray (as is known to happen), the entire formation breaks down. In the second formation, McFlynn is required to "mind" a much smaller central midfield partner. In the defensive variation McFlynn is again the chief distributor as Lavicka loathes to bypass the man in the hole.
McFlynn struggled in central defensive midfield last season, but reports suggest that Lavicka has him in mind for Stuart Musialik's old role. If he can make it work, it will instantly free up what was a battling midfield. If he can't, the captain may be benched for Rhyan Grant or Hiro Moriyasu.
This starting 11 has other weakness - Petratos plays outside his natural central midfield role, and the squad might lack height at set pieces against physical outfits. But a creative midfield core of Petratos, Antonis, Emerton and Carle is a vast improvement on Musialik, Hiro, McFlynn and Bridge, which is what Sydney was reduced to when injury and poor recruitment cruelled last year's campaign.
Sunday, April 17, 2011
Sydney FC wasting the worst of times
Sydney FC fans were supposed to enjoy a season of promise. Instead they endure a bitter malaise. The club is locked in a suffocating spiral as a dwindling tribe of disgruntled supporters show up to sing for a stuttering and terrified squad.
How did it come to this?
The champions built on their famous double by replacing an ageing and failed marquee in John Aloisi with a fringe Socceroo and genuine number 10. A front office headed by the impeccably credentialed Edwin Lugt and bankrolled by David Traktovenko stated the ambition to become a premier club in Asia (later the "preeminent club in Asia") and coach Viteslav Lavicka looked forward to warming up for his title defence with glamour preseason friendlies against Everton, Rangers, Blackburn and AEK Athens.
Now Lugt is gone. The Festival of Football was a lonely failure. Sydney FC could not even claim the false honour of a finals place. The Asian Champions League campaign is crippled, almost certainly beyond repair. Last season's mastermind is tottering despite his recent contract extension, undermined by his one dimensional approach, limited squad and failure to recruit players who can excel within his system.
I have already chronicled how the A League campaign fell apart under the weight of poor recruitment, a cascade of injuries and the unexpected acceleration in the quality of the A League. But the ACL is another matter.
Last week Sydney FC capitulated against Kashima Antlers. The club has failed to win a home game in the ACL and departs for unfriendly shores against superior opposition. Three points in Shanghai are an absolute necessity for a side that will face up against group leaders Kashima and Suwon with no clear idea of how to beat them.
More experienced scribes than I have already written about how Sydney FC's new low standards of ambition are a disgraceful mockery of the club's potential. Michael Cockerill believes that the club must recruit a Harry Kewell-level marquee player to haul itself out of a death spiral. I agree with the need to recruit a genuine marquee striker and believe that a Yorke or Fowler level signing would bring back 5,000 fans to the first home game, possibly more. But there is a particular type of striker that is required to entice the thousands of paying members to every home game.
Sydney FC fans demand more than football. We know that the SFS will never host a technical exhibition to match what we can see at home on television. But Sydney FC's greatest problem is its lack of flair. The idea of enduring 90 minutes of Mark Bridge and Dimitri Petratos playing out of position is more than most can bear. It was equally frustrating to witness the armband pass to a player not deemed worthy of a new contract in Stuart Musialik. How can a club not have more than one leader?
Sydney need flair and belief in equal measure. They need a swashbuckling striker who will show more heart than Bridge or Bruno Cazarine, and better touch than Juho Makela. Alex Brosque was popular because he believed in his own abilities. Precious few Sky Blues do the same - Shannon Cole's enduring popularity is based on his confidence, not his defensive positioning.
Kewell would fit the bill (hopefully his contract would include a requirement that he stay on his feet and play nice with the referees). Michael Owen's Premier League appeal would also do quite nicely. Miroslav Klose and Ruud Van Nistelrooy round out the quartet of impossible targets, but this is the ambition that Sydney FC must show.
More likely marquee targets are Vince Grella or Scott Chipperfield - neither would fill the flair void that Nicky Carle cannot match on his own. Whoever replaces Lugt will have one hell of a job finding the marquee man that Sydney rightly crave.
How did it come to this?
The champions built on their famous double by replacing an ageing and failed marquee in John Aloisi with a fringe Socceroo and genuine number 10. A front office headed by the impeccably credentialed Edwin Lugt and bankrolled by David Traktovenko stated the ambition to become a premier club in Asia (later the "preeminent club in Asia") and coach Viteslav Lavicka looked forward to warming up for his title defence with glamour preseason friendlies against Everton, Rangers, Blackburn and AEK Athens.
Now Lugt is gone. The Festival of Football was a lonely failure. Sydney FC could not even claim the false honour of a finals place. The Asian Champions League campaign is crippled, almost certainly beyond repair. Last season's mastermind is tottering despite his recent contract extension, undermined by his one dimensional approach, limited squad and failure to recruit players who can excel within his system.
I have already chronicled how the A League campaign fell apart under the weight of poor recruitment, a cascade of injuries and the unexpected acceleration in the quality of the A League. But the ACL is another matter.
Last week Sydney FC capitulated against Kashima Antlers. The club has failed to win a home game in the ACL and departs for unfriendly shores against superior opposition. Three points in Shanghai are an absolute necessity for a side that will face up against group leaders Kashima and Suwon with no clear idea of how to beat them.
More experienced scribes than I have already written about how Sydney FC's new low standards of ambition are a disgraceful mockery of the club's potential. Michael Cockerill believes that the club must recruit a Harry Kewell-level marquee player to haul itself out of a death spiral. I agree with the need to recruit a genuine marquee striker and believe that a Yorke or Fowler level signing would bring back 5,000 fans to the first home game, possibly more. But there is a particular type of striker that is required to entice the thousands of paying members to every home game.
Sydney FC fans demand more than football. We know that the SFS will never host a technical exhibition to match what we can see at home on television. But Sydney FC's greatest problem is its lack of flair. The idea of enduring 90 minutes of Mark Bridge and Dimitri Petratos playing out of position is more than most can bear. It was equally frustrating to witness the armband pass to a player not deemed worthy of a new contract in Stuart Musialik. How can a club not have more than one leader?
Sydney need flair and belief in equal measure. They need a swashbuckling striker who will show more heart than Bridge or Bruno Cazarine, and better touch than Juho Makela. Alex Brosque was popular because he believed in his own abilities. Precious few Sky Blues do the same - Shannon Cole's enduring popularity is based on his confidence, not his defensive positioning.
Kewell would fit the bill (hopefully his contract would include a requirement that he stay on his feet and play nice with the referees). Michael Owen's Premier League appeal would also do quite nicely. Miroslav Klose and Ruud Van Nistelrooy round out the quartet of impossible targets, but this is the ambition that Sydney FC must show.
More likely marquee targets are Vince Grella or Scott Chipperfield - neither would fill the flair void that Nicky Carle cannot match on his own. Whoever replaces Lugt will have one hell of a job finding the marquee man that Sydney rightly crave.
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
A Wasted Summer Part 3: Sydney FC's Crippled Magicians
Sydney FC's championship defence was destroyed the moment Nicky Carle succumbed to his second injury, and coach Viteslav Lavicka had only himself to blame.
The Czech oversaw a clearout of seasoned veterans but failed to replace his favourite player: Karol Kisel. The decision to fill Kisel's left midfield spot with young left back Scott Jamieson hamstrung Sydney early on, but was brutally exposed when Carle took to the sidelines.
When Steve Corica was injured last campaign, Kisel took his place at the head of Lavicka's diamond. Equally at home in the playmaking Number 10 slot or minding the left side of midfield, Kisel provided creativity and confidence on the ball.
When Nicky Carle keeled over for most of 2010, Lavicka's only options were to play Mark Bridge at 10 or promote his new signing Hiro Moriyasu, who was only just finding his feet. Bridge's catastrophic loss of form and Hiro's inability to threaten in front of goal left the team without a way to score goals or even hold up the ball and transition from defence to attack.
Lavicka's plan to shoehorn Jamieson into left midfield left the young wingback all at sea. He failed to threaten with his first touch and his delivery is too wayward to trust him with the ball at close quarters. If Lavicka had to play a fullback in midfield to accommodate Jamieson, Shannon Cole and Sung Hwan Byun, Cole would have been a much better choice.
Later injuries to Alex Brosque and Bridge sealed Sydney's fate, and the Cove only had Bruno to cheer as Sydney fizzled in front of goal.
The one positive to come from this sorry season is the emergence of Dimitri Petratos and Terry Antonis. Sydney must play these two youngsters as much as possible in 2011/2012. The A League rewards clubs that promote and develop young players, and the fans will flock to see future Socceroos learn their craft.
SQUAD REVIEW
ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS
Nick Carle, Terry Antonis, Dimitri Petratos, Kofi Danning, Brendan Gan, (Hiro Moriyasu)
Viteslav Lavicka's 4-4-2 diamond with conservative fullbacks requires creative input from the two wide midfielders. Unfortunately Lavicka chose to play Hiro Moriyasu and Terry McFlynn in front of Stuart Musialik, a conservative approach that lost Sydney games and fans.
Nicky Carle showed in the opening match against Melbourne that he can more than replace Steve Corica. Carle might lack goals and genuine pace, but his sublime touch gives Sydney the rarest of players in the A League: one who can hold up the play under pressure, play the right pass and unlock a defence with a moment of magic.
If Carle stays fit for most of the next season (and his career shows no reason to doubt he will) Sydney will make the finals. If Lavicka can play Karol Kisel or another more offensively minded player with Carle in midfield, Sydney may well go further. Sydney must attack from the first game to win back their fickle fans.
The whinging minority who call Carle a false marquee should consider the gross wages payed to John Aloisi, a player who only came good for six weeks in two years, and measure Carle's contribution at the end of his contract. Carle's wages are far from obscene and I am confident he will prove to be value for money.
News that Sydney were chasing Matt McKay showed welcome ambition and is a great relief: it means that the club has finally acknowledged the gap left by Karol Kisel in left midfield (just in time for Kisel's return). But Brisbane would never let their captain leave for free and Sydney cannot afford a transfer fee. This transfer is extremely unlikely and Sydney would be better served looking elsewhere for versatile wide midfielders: Scott Chipperfield and Brett Emerton, anyone?
Terry Antonis found precious little time on the pitch this season but Sydney must promote and develop his talent. Antonis must play, and in Carle's position, at every opportunity next year (whenever Carle is injured, suspended or tired). Antonis destroyed Wellington in February and his understanding with Dimitri Petratos in that game is surely a sign of good times to come. In that match he ran at players, picked the right pass and controlled the ball despite atrocious conditions. We can only hope he does not move overseas too early.
Dimitri Petratos is an interesting case. He has Mark Bridge's versatility but twice the ability. Petratos can pick a pass, score a goal (his air swing against the Victory aside) and occupies intelligent positions. I still believe his best position is attacking central midfielder and I hope he will find a home on the left side of midfield, but his work as Bruno Cazarine's support striker at the end of the season was inspiring. Sydney should sign him up long term and Petratos deserves to start matches.
Sadly Kofi Danning has not come on in the same way. Danning is caught in a terrible bind. His pace and enthusiasm dazzles against players his age, but his first touch can be dire and is not up to A League standard. Danning's greatest problem is his coach's system. Lavicka only plays Danning up front as a last resort and the Czech rarely plays with out and out wingers.
Now that Lavicka has re-signed with Sydney for another season, it is time for Danning to leave. Though his departure would leave Sydney short of genuine pace, the kid is at the age where he has to play. Another season on the bench will do him no favours and he does not fit within Sydney's best 20. Danning may be a likeable lad and a crowd favourite but he has not lived up to the hype.
Brendan Gan is another player who looks likely to leave. Gan should have slotted into a wide midfield role after Kisel departed, but Lavicka is clearly reluctant to pick a player who divides fans. Gan is keen and adequate, and has a cool finish, but he will probably have to leave and fight for a spot elsewhere to prove his worth.
It is a great shame that the Fury are no more. Players such as Gan and Danning could have found a home there, but will probably end up on the Gold Coast or across the Tasman instead.
MARK BRIDGE
Bridge is the only player afforded his own section throughout my season review because he is a player without a natural position. He also deserves special mention because he was undoubtedly the major disappointment of 2010/11.
This season showed Bridge to be a jack of all trades and a master of none. 1 goal and 6 assists in 19 games would be a poor return from a winger, but Bridge has played as a target man, playmaking number 10, wide midfielder and second striker.
Unfortunately he was not particularly good at any of those positions. Bridge lacks the pace to play winger, the vision and confidence to slot in at Number 10, the acceleration and lethality to excel at second striker and the sheer dynamism to lead the line.
Bridge looks most at home up front with his back to goal, and suffered badly when Nick Carle's injury forced him into attacking midfield.
Players dream of this kind of opportunity. Bridge was asked to run the offence for the A League defending champions. He tried hard but became The Cove's greatest disappointment since John Aloisi.
By late spring Bridge lacked the confidence to turn on the ball when had metres of space around him. Teams crowded him early, destroyed his confidence and reduced him to training drill passes and robotic movement off the ball. His failure to close down properly also left the team dreadfully exposed against overlapping fullbacks.
Bridge tried hard and occasionally put in a good performance. But the former Young Socceroo has suffered the curse of versatility. A sustained spell at striker produced his best form last season, but the A League has moved on. Other clubs have Van Dyk, Smeltz, Thompson and Fowler, and Sydney's "Killer Bs" though never truly prolific, could just about match that standard.
But Bridge never got near the input of the new and improved number 10s: Broich, Flores, Perez and Amini, and is certainly no Carlos Hernandez or Daniel. If the man at the top of the diamond goes into his shell, the team falls apart, and Bridge failed all too often.
It is not too late for Bridge, who clings to his new and improved contract while young talent like Matt Jurman departs for bigger money elsewhere. Like Aloisi Bridge may redeem himself and he does not lack raw ability. He needs to back himself next time he gets on the ball. He must play with the freedom denied him by the shackles of his own mind.
The Czech oversaw a clearout of seasoned veterans but failed to replace his favourite player: Karol Kisel. The decision to fill Kisel's left midfield spot with young left back Scott Jamieson hamstrung Sydney early on, but was brutally exposed when Carle took to the sidelines.
When Steve Corica was injured last campaign, Kisel took his place at the head of Lavicka's diamond. Equally at home in the playmaking Number 10 slot or minding the left side of midfield, Kisel provided creativity and confidence on the ball.
When Nicky Carle keeled over for most of 2010, Lavicka's only options were to play Mark Bridge at 10 or promote his new signing Hiro Moriyasu, who was only just finding his feet. Bridge's catastrophic loss of form and Hiro's inability to threaten in front of goal left the team without a way to score goals or even hold up the ball and transition from defence to attack.
Lavicka's plan to shoehorn Jamieson into left midfield left the young wingback all at sea. He failed to threaten with his first touch and his delivery is too wayward to trust him with the ball at close quarters. If Lavicka had to play a fullback in midfield to accommodate Jamieson, Shannon Cole and Sung Hwan Byun, Cole would have been a much better choice.
Later injuries to Alex Brosque and Bridge sealed Sydney's fate, and the Cove only had Bruno to cheer as Sydney fizzled in front of goal.
The one positive to come from this sorry season is the emergence of Dimitri Petratos and Terry Antonis. Sydney must play these two youngsters as much as possible in 2011/2012. The A League rewards clubs that promote and develop young players, and the fans will flock to see future Socceroos learn their craft.
SQUAD REVIEW
ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS
Nick Carle, Terry Antonis, Dimitri Petratos, Kofi Danning, Brendan Gan, (Hiro Moriyasu)
Viteslav Lavicka's 4-4-2 diamond with conservative fullbacks requires creative input from the two wide midfielders. Unfortunately Lavicka chose to play Hiro Moriyasu and Terry McFlynn in front of Stuart Musialik, a conservative approach that lost Sydney games and fans.
Nicky Carle showed in the opening match against Melbourne that he can more than replace Steve Corica. Carle might lack goals and genuine pace, but his sublime touch gives Sydney the rarest of players in the A League: one who can hold up the play under pressure, play the right pass and unlock a defence with a moment of magic.
If Carle stays fit for most of the next season (and his career shows no reason to doubt he will) Sydney will make the finals. If Lavicka can play Karol Kisel or another more offensively minded player with Carle in midfield, Sydney may well go further. Sydney must attack from the first game to win back their fickle fans.
The whinging minority who call Carle a false marquee should consider the gross wages payed to John Aloisi, a player who only came good for six weeks in two years, and measure Carle's contribution at the end of his contract. Carle's wages are far from obscene and I am confident he will prove to be value for money.
News that Sydney were chasing Matt McKay showed welcome ambition and is a great relief: it means that the club has finally acknowledged the gap left by Karol Kisel in left midfield (just in time for Kisel's return). But Brisbane would never let their captain leave for free and Sydney cannot afford a transfer fee. This transfer is extremely unlikely and Sydney would be better served looking elsewhere for versatile wide midfielders: Scott Chipperfield and Brett Emerton, anyone?
Terry Antonis found precious little time on the pitch this season but Sydney must promote and develop his talent. Antonis must play, and in Carle's position, at every opportunity next year (whenever Carle is injured, suspended or tired). Antonis destroyed Wellington in February and his understanding with Dimitri Petratos in that game is surely a sign of good times to come. In that match he ran at players, picked the right pass and controlled the ball despite atrocious conditions. We can only hope he does not move overseas too early.
Dimitri Petratos is an interesting case. He has Mark Bridge's versatility but twice the ability. Petratos can pick a pass, score a goal (his air swing against the Victory aside) and occupies intelligent positions. I still believe his best position is attacking central midfielder and I hope he will find a home on the left side of midfield, but his work as Bruno Cazarine's support striker at the end of the season was inspiring. Sydney should sign him up long term and Petratos deserves to start matches.
Sadly Kofi Danning has not come on in the same way. Danning is caught in a terrible bind. His pace and enthusiasm dazzles against players his age, but his first touch can be dire and is not up to A League standard. Danning's greatest problem is his coach's system. Lavicka only plays Danning up front as a last resort and the Czech rarely plays with out and out wingers.
Now that Lavicka has re-signed with Sydney for another season, it is time for Danning to leave. Though his departure would leave Sydney short of genuine pace, the kid is at the age where he has to play. Another season on the bench will do him no favours and he does not fit within Sydney's best 20. Danning may be a likeable lad and a crowd favourite but he has not lived up to the hype.
Brendan Gan is another player who looks likely to leave. Gan should have slotted into a wide midfield role after Kisel departed, but Lavicka is clearly reluctant to pick a player who divides fans. Gan is keen and adequate, and has a cool finish, but he will probably have to leave and fight for a spot elsewhere to prove his worth.
It is a great shame that the Fury are no more. Players such as Gan and Danning could have found a home there, but will probably end up on the Gold Coast or across the Tasman instead.
MARK BRIDGE
Bridge is the only player afforded his own section throughout my season review because he is a player without a natural position. He also deserves special mention because he was undoubtedly the major disappointment of 2010/11.
This season showed Bridge to be a jack of all trades and a master of none. 1 goal and 6 assists in 19 games would be a poor return from a winger, but Bridge has played as a target man, playmaking number 10, wide midfielder and second striker.
Unfortunately he was not particularly good at any of those positions. Bridge lacks the pace to play winger, the vision and confidence to slot in at Number 10, the acceleration and lethality to excel at second striker and the sheer dynamism to lead the line.
Bridge looks most at home up front with his back to goal, and suffered badly when Nick Carle's injury forced him into attacking midfield.
Players dream of this kind of opportunity. Bridge was asked to run the offence for the A League defending champions. He tried hard but became The Cove's greatest disappointment since John Aloisi.
By late spring Bridge lacked the confidence to turn on the ball when had metres of space around him. Teams crowded him early, destroyed his confidence and reduced him to training drill passes and robotic movement off the ball. His failure to close down properly also left the team dreadfully exposed against overlapping fullbacks.
Bridge tried hard and occasionally put in a good performance. But the former Young Socceroo has suffered the curse of versatility. A sustained spell at striker produced his best form last season, but the A League has moved on. Other clubs have Van Dyk, Smeltz, Thompson and Fowler, and Sydney's "Killer Bs" though never truly prolific, could just about match that standard.
But Bridge never got near the input of the new and improved number 10s: Broich, Flores, Perez and Amini, and is certainly no Carlos Hernandez or Daniel. If the man at the top of the diamond goes into his shell, the team falls apart, and Bridge failed all too often.
It is not too late for Bridge, who clings to his new and improved contract while young talent like Matt Jurman departs for bigger money elsewhere. Like Aloisi Bridge may redeem himself and he does not lack raw ability. He needs to back himself next time he gets on the ball. He must play with the freedom denied him by the shackles of his own mind.
Saturday, January 15, 2011
Game 25 - Sydney FC 1 vs Melbourne Victory 1 - 15/01/11
Melbourne had three of the five clear cut chances in this enthralling match but Sydney should have dominated a contest so full of hope and despair that Juho Makela's equalizing goal was, for a good two seconds after it hit the net, too good to be believed by half the crowd.
Sydney raced back to the halfway line ball in hand and buoyed by stunned supporters, somehow believing that after failing to score for 91 minutes, they could thrash one into the net in 90 seconds. Too little, too late for Viteslav Lavicka, who will be lucky to survive the week.
Finals football was a forlorn hope after the devastating draw with the Fury back in October's three-game stretch. Last night's failure has cut the cord. Sydney are six points back and have played two more games than the sixth-placed Jets.
The case against Sydney FC is simple. If you can't beat your biggest rivals when they are missing four of their best five outfield players, when you are playing in front of your biggest home crowd, when you have 16 shots at goal in the first half, then you don't deserve to play in the finals.
At halftime I wrote: "The game has the feel of a Sydney FC training run with everyone missing their shots. I fear a sucker punch."
If Juho Makela was fit to start, the Sky Blues would have won the match. If Alex Brosque was fit to play it would have been a rout. If Hiro Moriyasu's shot had slid inside the post, if Dimitri Petratos had even touched the ball...
A title defence should not depend on wishes or sentiment. Sydney have drawn or lost 19 out of 25 games this season. That the Sky Blues have a mathematical chance of finals football is an insult to other sides.
Judging by last night's glorious first half what hurts the most is what might have been. Sydney flew at Melbourne unburdened by the doubts that have crippled this campaign. Melbourne had the two best chances of the half but it seemed a moot point, such was Sydney's dominance.
The first 45 minutes were encapsulated by one Sydney movement when Nicky Carle rode a challenge then back-heeled the ball to kick off a raid that ended in a shot off target. Carle dominated the first half in the same way that he dominated the opening game of the season. How Sydney have suffered under the poor form of Mark Bridge.
Melbourne were desperate to slow the game down but still had the best chances of the first 45. Stephan Keller inexplicably decided to let a sliding cross roll past him along the six yard box and straight onto Danny Allsopp's boot, and Liam Reddy was lucky to see a feeble header spring from Matt Jurman's last-ditch challenge on Allsopp, whose movement troubled Sydney's back two all night.
By the 35th minute some Sydney players were getting restless. Bruno Cazarine put in more petulance than workrate and Juho Makela's drifting runs were a welcome addition after he came on for Hiro Moriyasu at the 55th minute. If Alex Brosque returns, Big Bruno will be lucky to keep his place. Stephan Keller's 80th minute shot from near the centre circle was selfish, stupid and hardly the thing to invigorate his supporters or his side. Skipper Terry McFlynn should not be allowing this sort of thing.
Nicky Carle deserved his man of the match award but his detractors (and there are many) will quite rightly point out that he failed to place a shot on target and that his cross to Makela may well have been a mis-cued shot. He was also peripheral in the first fifteen minutes of the second half when Sydney's passing was comical at best and atrocious at worst. McFlynn and Bruno, then Byun and Makela made pathetic efforts to attack down the right hand side and Carle should have demanded the ball to restore Sydney's possession.
All that said, Carle played in Petratos for what should have been a certain goal, put the ball right onto Makela's foot for his strike and tore Melbourne to shreds in the first 45. Things are looking up for what will be a very tough Asian Champions League campaign.
18-year-old Dimitri Petratos has played in four different positions: across midfield and as a support striker. He ran himself into the ground last night but looks most at home with players in front of him. The air swing was poor and but hopefully his confidence is shored up strong foundations. Does Viteslav Lavicka have the wherewithal to slot Petratos back into midfield before he has too much time to dwell on his miss? Time will tell.
Which brings us to the boss himself. If the Sydney board show the ruthlessness of their predecessors then this failure - and it is a failure - should be Czechmate for Lavicka.
It depends on the players. If they have lost all confidence in Lavicka then he should be congratulated for last season and retired. The first half performance does not indicate that things have degenerated that far. But Lavicka seems unable to improve the team at halftime which is when a manager should be at his best.
Few managers have enjoyed this much patience from a board. Lavicka has recruited the wrong replacements for the wrong departures, has stuck with the the wrong tactics at the wrong times and failed to shore up the confidence of a previously dominant and swaggering team.
One more game without a win should seal his departure. If the looming "mid-January" board meeting comes before Sunday's game against the high-flying Mariner, Lavicka may not get even that chance.
EDIT: One thing I forgot to mention was the fantastic contribution from The Cove. They were in amazing form with another brilliant tifo, and here's hoping everyone comes back for the final game of the season against the Phoenix next month. If you missed it, here's a link I snagged from parkingthebus on Twitter.
Sydney raced back to the halfway line ball in hand and buoyed by stunned supporters, somehow believing that after failing to score for 91 minutes, they could thrash one into the net in 90 seconds. Too little, too late for Viteslav Lavicka, who will be lucky to survive the week.
Finals football was a forlorn hope after the devastating draw with the Fury back in October's three-game stretch. Last night's failure has cut the cord. Sydney are six points back and have played two more games than the sixth-placed Jets.
The case against Sydney FC is simple. If you can't beat your biggest rivals when they are missing four of their best five outfield players, when you are playing in front of your biggest home crowd, when you have 16 shots at goal in the first half, then you don't deserve to play in the finals.
At halftime I wrote: "The game has the feel of a Sydney FC training run with everyone missing their shots. I fear a sucker punch."
If Juho Makela was fit to start, the Sky Blues would have won the match. If Alex Brosque was fit to play it would have been a rout. If Hiro Moriyasu's shot had slid inside the post, if Dimitri Petratos had even touched the ball...
A title defence should not depend on wishes or sentiment. Sydney have drawn or lost 19 out of 25 games this season. That the Sky Blues have a mathematical chance of finals football is an insult to other sides.
Judging by last night's glorious first half what hurts the most is what might have been. Sydney flew at Melbourne unburdened by the doubts that have crippled this campaign. Melbourne had the two best chances of the half but it seemed a moot point, such was Sydney's dominance.
The first 45 minutes were encapsulated by one Sydney movement when Nicky Carle rode a challenge then back-heeled the ball to kick off a raid that ended in a shot off target. Carle dominated the first half in the same way that he dominated the opening game of the season. How Sydney have suffered under the poor form of Mark Bridge.
Melbourne were desperate to slow the game down but still had the best chances of the first 45. Stephan Keller inexplicably decided to let a sliding cross roll past him along the six yard box and straight onto Danny Allsopp's boot, and Liam Reddy was lucky to see a feeble header spring from Matt Jurman's last-ditch challenge on Allsopp, whose movement troubled Sydney's back two all night.
By the 35th minute some Sydney players were getting restless. Bruno Cazarine put in more petulance than workrate and Juho Makela's drifting runs were a welcome addition after he came on for Hiro Moriyasu at the 55th minute. If Alex Brosque returns, Big Bruno will be lucky to keep his place. Stephan Keller's 80th minute shot from near the centre circle was selfish, stupid and hardly the thing to invigorate his supporters or his side. Skipper Terry McFlynn should not be allowing this sort of thing.
Nicky Carle deserved his man of the match award but his detractors (and there are many) will quite rightly point out that he failed to place a shot on target and that his cross to Makela may well have been a mis-cued shot. He was also peripheral in the first fifteen minutes of the second half when Sydney's passing was comical at best and atrocious at worst. McFlynn and Bruno, then Byun and Makela made pathetic efforts to attack down the right hand side and Carle should have demanded the ball to restore Sydney's possession.
All that said, Carle played in Petratos for what should have been a certain goal, put the ball right onto Makela's foot for his strike and tore Melbourne to shreds in the first 45. Things are looking up for what will be a very tough Asian Champions League campaign.
18-year-old Dimitri Petratos has played in four different positions: across midfield and as a support striker. He ran himself into the ground last night but looks most at home with players in front of him. The air swing was poor and but hopefully his confidence is shored up strong foundations. Does Viteslav Lavicka have the wherewithal to slot Petratos back into midfield before he has too much time to dwell on his miss? Time will tell.
Which brings us to the boss himself. If the Sydney board show the ruthlessness of their predecessors then this failure - and it is a failure - should be Czechmate for Lavicka.
It depends on the players. If they have lost all confidence in Lavicka then he should be congratulated for last season and retired. The first half performance does not indicate that things have degenerated that far. But Lavicka seems unable to improve the team at halftime which is when a manager should be at his best.
Few managers have enjoyed this much patience from a board. Lavicka has recruited the wrong replacements for the wrong departures, has stuck with the the wrong tactics at the wrong times and failed to shore up the confidence of a previously dominant and swaggering team.
One more game without a win should seal his departure. If the looming "mid-January" board meeting comes before Sunday's game against the high-flying Mariner, Lavicka may not get even that chance.
EDIT: One thing I forgot to mention was the fantastic contribution from The Cove. They were in amazing form with another brilliant tifo, and here's hoping everyone comes back for the final game of the season against the Phoenix next month. If you missed it, here's a link I snagged from parkingthebus on Twitter.
Sunday, December 12, 2010
Game 19 - Sydney FC 0 vs Queensland Roar 1 - 12/12/10
"It could have been worse."
That is the frightening defeatism that has infected Sydney FC. This season has seen a champion squad plunge into despair and disrepair, with nary a captain or coach able to bail the water out of a sinking ship.
To say that Sydney FC won the second half flatters the hosts mightily. Brisbane rarely got out of second gear. Imagine what they could accomplish with a top class striker. The Roar worked their way down field methodically and brazenly, while Sydney struggled to play out of their own half.
All the old bad signs were there. Stephan Keller thumping the ball long and wide. Static fullbacks hugging the touch line. Players pointing at positions where they expected each other to be, five seconds after the ball had gone. Sydney's playmaker, either Mark Bridge or Terry Antonis, settling for occupying a defender instead of running them ragged.
Viteslav Lavicka should guide the club to the Asian Champions League but Sydney FC should not be offering him an Alan Pardew-esque five and a half year deal. Lavicka clearly arrived with Plan A - the same 4-4-2 diamond that Sydney have played for a year and a half - and no Plan B, despite Brisbane playing the same way they have all season.
Lavicka identified that Gan and Antonis were struggling but changed personnel without attacking the cause of the problem. Few managers have disrupted Brisbane this season but the diamond left Antonis and Bridge completely impotent - exhausted by defence and desperately out of position in transition attack. Brisbane apparently enjoyed 68 percent of possession in the first half. I'm surprised it wasn't more.
To go man for man, as Sydney were unable to do:
Ivan Necevski should have done better to block Kosta Barbarouses's cool finish but made some smart saves in either half. A good back up option for sure, but it seems Crazy Ivan has found his level.
Shannon Cole was easily Sydney's most impressive player over the 90 minutes. He supplied Sydney's only moment of skill with a cool backheel in the second half, put in a few threatening runs and kept Thomas Broich reasonably quiet. Cole backed himself in the tackle and on the ball, which was something few other Sydney players seemed willing to do. His combination with Dimitri Petratos was encouraging and should be nurtured.
Sung-Hwan Byun put in possibly his worst shift in a Sky Blue shirt. Apart from supplying atrocious delivery from wide areas throughout the match, Byun was one of many Sydney players who seemed more intent on ordering his teammates around than getting in a helpful position himself. Byun's mind seems off the job and Scott Jamieson cannot return soon enough.
Hayden Foxe and Stephan Keller may have been a great central combination five years ago. But Foxe's distribution has degraded over the past month and Keller's has probably been atrocious his entire career. That Brisbane did not win by more is evidence of their honest hard work but they were often caught too far apart, too far from their Solorzano, too deep (to cover their lack of pace) and too scared of the ball. It is time for Lavicka to recruit some replacements.
Sydney's under fire manager was forced to substitute Brendan Gan and Terry Antonis at halftime and both youngsters deserved the hook. Hopefully Antonis will not stay benched for long. The lad has undoubted ability but today's match was too cruel a test so early. His confidence must now be sand-bagged, not sabotaged. Sydney's first responsibility was too relieve defensive pressure and neither Gan nor Antonis contributed, while Terry McFlynn's performance was similarly lacking.
Terry McFlynn may be a Foundation Player but he needs to be a proper captain. It has been too long since McFlynn, or any Sydney player, took a match by the scruff of the neck. It is McFlynn's duty to lead by example, but doing a job is no longer enough in a Sydney side of much lower quality than last year's edition.
Hiro Moriyasu also put in a fairly abject performance. He was played in what is allegedly his preferred position at the base of Sydney's midfield, but lost possession time and again, took too long to select an option, was weak in the tackle and failed to interact properly with his defence. Hiro is best employed as a box to box harasser and lacks the composure to play as the screening anchor. An in-form Stuart Musialik is a better option, but Sydney have precious few players in form at the moment.
Big bad Bruno Cazarine was obviously not fully fit and played for free kicks before halftime. Alex Brosque was dynamic, inspirational and alone.
Mark Bridge was absolutely anonymous. Again. His new contract should be read to him like the Riot Act. Hopefully a rocket up the backside can push him past the barrier of his natural abilities. Bridge is an enigma without the ability to justify his inconsistency. Nicky Carle, it has been said too often, cannot return soon enough.
A champion side should not regress so poorly. A great manager should not allow them to. Great managers adapt. Great players overcome adversity. Sydney FC simply flounder while their crowds dwindle and The Cove grows quieter. Sydney's names were not cheered and the side was barely applauded onto the park.
Something is out of kilter and it is not just Nicky Carle's back.
That is the frightening defeatism that has infected Sydney FC. This season has seen a champion squad plunge into despair and disrepair, with nary a captain or coach able to bail the water out of a sinking ship.
To say that Sydney FC won the second half flatters the hosts mightily. Brisbane rarely got out of second gear. Imagine what they could accomplish with a top class striker. The Roar worked their way down field methodically and brazenly, while Sydney struggled to play out of their own half.
All the old bad signs were there. Stephan Keller thumping the ball long and wide. Static fullbacks hugging the touch line. Players pointing at positions where they expected each other to be, five seconds after the ball had gone. Sydney's playmaker, either Mark Bridge or Terry Antonis, settling for occupying a defender instead of running them ragged.
Viteslav Lavicka should guide the club to the Asian Champions League but Sydney FC should not be offering him an Alan Pardew-esque five and a half year deal. Lavicka clearly arrived with Plan A - the same 4-4-2 diamond that Sydney have played for a year and a half - and no Plan B, despite Brisbane playing the same way they have all season.
Lavicka identified that Gan and Antonis were struggling but changed personnel without attacking the cause of the problem. Few managers have disrupted Brisbane this season but the diamond left Antonis and Bridge completely impotent - exhausted by defence and desperately out of position in transition attack. Brisbane apparently enjoyed 68 percent of possession in the first half. I'm surprised it wasn't more.
To go man for man, as Sydney were unable to do:
Ivan Necevski should have done better to block Kosta Barbarouses's cool finish but made some smart saves in either half. A good back up option for sure, but it seems Crazy Ivan has found his level.
Shannon Cole was easily Sydney's most impressive player over the 90 minutes. He supplied Sydney's only moment of skill with a cool backheel in the second half, put in a few threatening runs and kept Thomas Broich reasonably quiet. Cole backed himself in the tackle and on the ball, which was something few other Sydney players seemed willing to do. His combination with Dimitri Petratos was encouraging and should be nurtured.
Sung-Hwan Byun put in possibly his worst shift in a Sky Blue shirt. Apart from supplying atrocious delivery from wide areas throughout the match, Byun was one of many Sydney players who seemed more intent on ordering his teammates around than getting in a helpful position himself. Byun's mind seems off the job and Scott Jamieson cannot return soon enough.
Hayden Foxe and Stephan Keller may have been a great central combination five years ago. But Foxe's distribution has degraded over the past month and Keller's has probably been atrocious his entire career. That Brisbane did not win by more is evidence of their honest hard work but they were often caught too far apart, too far from their Solorzano, too deep (to cover their lack of pace) and too scared of the ball. It is time for Lavicka to recruit some replacements.
Sydney's under fire manager was forced to substitute Brendan Gan and Terry Antonis at halftime and both youngsters deserved the hook. Hopefully Antonis will not stay benched for long. The lad has undoubted ability but today's match was too cruel a test so early. His confidence must now be sand-bagged, not sabotaged. Sydney's first responsibility was too relieve defensive pressure and neither Gan nor Antonis contributed, while Terry McFlynn's performance was similarly lacking.
Terry McFlynn may be a Foundation Player but he needs to be a proper captain. It has been too long since McFlynn, or any Sydney player, took a match by the scruff of the neck. It is McFlynn's duty to lead by example, but doing a job is no longer enough in a Sydney side of much lower quality than last year's edition.
Hiro Moriyasu also put in a fairly abject performance. He was played in what is allegedly his preferred position at the base of Sydney's midfield, but lost possession time and again, took too long to select an option, was weak in the tackle and failed to interact properly with his defence. Hiro is best employed as a box to box harasser and lacks the composure to play as the screening anchor. An in-form Stuart Musialik is a better option, but Sydney have precious few players in form at the moment.
Big bad Bruno Cazarine was obviously not fully fit and played for free kicks before halftime. Alex Brosque was dynamic, inspirational and alone.
Mark Bridge was absolutely anonymous. Again. His new contract should be read to him like the Riot Act. Hopefully a rocket up the backside can push him past the barrier of his natural abilities. Bridge is an enigma without the ability to justify his inconsistency. Nicky Carle, it has been said too often, cannot return soon enough.
A champion side should not regress so poorly. A great manager should not allow them to. Great managers adapt. Great players overcome adversity. Sydney FC simply flounder while their crowds dwindle and The Cove grows quieter. Sydney's names were not cheered and the side was barely applauded onto the park.
Something is out of kilter and it is not just Nicky Carle's back.
Monday, August 30, 2010
Game 4 - Sydney FC 1 vs Central Coast Mariners 1 - 28/8/2010
Sydney FC is a club in trouble, but the boss has again sounded the right notes of calm and reflection. Whether he meant to describe his players as "frustrated" and not "frustrating" is another question.
It is too early to abandon talk of a title defence but far too soon for players to lose their heads. Saturday’s (frankly disappointing) home crowd had bought the right to boo referee Matthew Breeze, but the amount of dissent on the field was understandable and not excusable. We pay to sing, cheer good play and occasionally boo bad football. The Sky Blues are paid to play football and should have gotten on with it.
Last season Sydney FC collectively dominated their opponent. Now they bitch and moan, often to each other, and did so long before Breeze’s latest bungle spoiled Saturday night’s emotional derby against Central Coast
But before examining Sydney FC, let’s bag the ref. I am grateful to every person who becomes a referee, but as Jesse Fink so rightly put it, for the FFA to honour Breeze’s 100th game after the final whistle was high farce. How the referee and linesmen combined to miss the Mariners’ handball, award the penalty and send off Liam Reddy must be explained. Obviously any keeper in that situation risks giving away a spotkick but Reddy was far from the last man, Perez was not heading “towards goal”, and it was demonstrably not a “clear goalscoring opportunity” after Perez kicked the ball away from goal and towards onrushing defenders.
To add acid to the wound Sydney
The tragic fact is that this game underlined the saddest and most cast-iron convention in football: if you are fouled in the box, you must fall over or you will never win a penalty.
Forget video replays, forget retrospective punishments: give teams a chance to get a spotkick honestly and they might just stop falling over in disgraceful fashion.
Breeze said of his milestone: “Like a player, these achievements are nice at the time and I’m sure I will look back on moments like this with fondness.”
“Like a player”? We can liken Breeze to Clayton Zane, another Australian whose game went downhill after his first sniff of Confederations Cup glory.
As for Sydney Sydney
Scott Jamieson looks a promising player but a natural left back and he and Byun are not yet gelling. While Danning looks destined to return to the bench, it will be interesting to see who loses their place to Terry McFlynn and (hopefully) Alex Brosque after Rhyan Grant’s impressive performance.
Stuart Musialik again coughed up the odd cataclysmic error, particularly early on, and though Sydney
Nicky Carle, so dominant in that game, was sorely underused and no other Sydney Mark Bridge
No Sky Blue seemed to think about testing the Mariners’ 18-year-old debutant keeper from range. No cross seemed likely to find a target or test the nerves of young Matthew Ryan, until Rhyan Grant’s goal, which was celebrated like a 30-yard match winner and not a barely-earned gift. Few passes were delivered with pace or invention and the red card robbed Lavicka of his chance to switch things up in the second half.
Give Graham Arnold his due. He compressed the Mariners around the centre circle and dared Sydney Sydney Central Coast
One of the compensating pleasures for A League fans shorn of world class talent is to watch the game evolve season by season. It appears that this vintage of the A League has moved on markedly and Sydney FC is swinging in the breeze.
Lavicka’s men have been worked out. Their next challenge is: don’t panic.
Sunday, August 8, 2010
Game 1 - Sydney FC 3 vs Melbourne Victory 3 - 7/8/2010
Pity the fans that did not turn up. Sydney FC’s A League opener was a game rich with drama and ability, passion and promise. Sydney and Melbourne showed their best and worst and a genuine star enjoyed a second (or third) homecoming in a contest that stamped last season’s great rivals as this year’s strongest contenders.
It appears that Vitezslav Lavicka flirted with a flat 4-4-2 during the preseason to find a back up plan for a Sydney FC shorn of Nicky Carle. With a fully fit marquee man the Sydney diamond was restored and after a stifled opening, Carle slotted comfortably in behind the gifted Alex Brosque and Mark Bridge. The results were more than encouraging.
Sydney’s first choice B-B-C frontline is technically adroit, reasonably hard-working and comfortable working without the ball to find space. Each player can take on a man, hit the flanks, run a good line in behind the defence or hold up the ball in their own way.
Karol Kisel will remain a Sydney FC hero but Carle surpassed Kisel's erratic contributions by providing some welcome composure and true creativity. And while the Cove’s fantastic banners at the start of the match hailed the contribution of Steve Corica, by fulltime the boys in blue were praising their eternal skipper’s true successor. Carle is a genuine playmaker, a genuine marquee and a number 10 to match Carlos Hernandez and Jason Culina. His flicks and tricks won him the space and time to pick a pass and the growing admiration of a responsive crowd. Melbourne eventually stood off him after he defied any attempt to put him off the ball and his game.
Frankly, if Carle plays that well throughout the season, Sydney will tear at least one team apart at the seams and it was a shame that his match-controlling performance did not produce more goals.
Bridge and Brosque did well without breaking the game open and one senses that if Lavicka had signed a third striker Bridge would have been substituted halfway through the second half. Sydney FC has never really enjoyed the services of a Smeltz-like predator and the club is now blessed with creativity. What Sydney need is someone to smash the ball into the back of the net and hopefully Bridge will become that man. After all, it would surprise if Sydney can generate that many good chances against Melbourne again this season.
Sadly for Sydney, an A League match is rarely won by the front men. Two of Melbourne’s three goals (and, to be fair, two of Sydney’s) were mostly the result of poor positioning and decision-making in possession and then defence. Only two Victory players hit the box for the cross that led to their first goal, but both outfoxed five Sydney defenders. Mate Dugandzic’s equalising strike was well-taken but he did not have a foot, hand or body near him when he first received the ball. And the third goal resembled a FIFA 2006 play as Melbourne passed their way through the Sydney midfield and defence with consummate ease.
The rot started at the front as Sydney forgot to close down collectively after their second goal. With Carle drawn forward and Brosque and Bridge wide, Scott Jamieson got unsurprisingly lost as part of a three-man holding midfield. Sydney’s flanks were exposed and the central defenders seemed unsure of whether to tag and follow or pass on their man. Jamieson had an unhappy match crowned by an air swing at a beckoning strike on goal, but his preseason form was encouraging and he will find his feet.
At least Sydney were assured when they could put their foot on the ball. The Victory missed a number of first-team players but apart from Melbourne’s seven minutes of madness, Sydney almost totally dominated the match and enforced their will from back to front.
Skipper Terry McFlynn played a strong game and took his goal well, while Stuart Musialik put in his usual performance: an excellent, controlling game apart from one or two dreadful errors that put his team under pressure. Musialik is a vital player for Sydney and when he returned to the side last season the Sky Blues rocketed towards glory. If he can continue to reduce his errors in possession he should again find himself in the frame for the Socceroos.
Another man who delivered welcome composure was Hayden Foxe. Foxe slipped straight into Simon Colosimo’s quarterback role and looks to be a marvellous acquisition. But with a Keller/Foxe partnership Sydney clearly lack pace in central defence. If Lavicka sticks with this combination he will be stretching his tactical blanket like mad. It will be fascinating to see how Lavicka can sit his team high and play a short passing game with overlapping fullbacks and simultaneously cover runs from fast strikers with a fairly plodding central defensive combination.
Presumably Foxe will miss games due to injury and recovery and the burden will fall heavily on Seb Ryall, who is yet to convince. Ryall put in a good shift at right back and offered a surprising threat in attack, but was caught out of position during several of Melbourne’s lethal moments. Shannon Cole will rightfully push him all the way this season and will probably start games against lesser teams than Melbourne.
On the other side, it is perhaps best to simply say that Jamieson and Byun worked hard on the pitch but have work to do off it.
Much more has been said elsewhere about the "disappointing" crowd. I was stunned when the figure of 12,000 came up – it felt that at least 16,000 were in the stadium. The crowd enjoyed a fantastic atmosphere, thrilling goals, some brilliant skill – mostly from Carle – and a passionate match that was laudably contested through ball-on-the-ground, short passing football. I was disappointed by the people who didn't turn up, including the other 12,000 Sydney fans who made it to the Valentine's Day fixture, or some of the 40,000 who went to the Everton match, but couldn't be bothered watching Sydney's opener. Those who were there were fantastic and deserved the spectacle they received.
So if you know a Sydney football fan, buy them a ticket for August 28. Because Carle and company are well worth the meagre price of admission.
It appears that Vitezslav Lavicka flirted with a flat 4-4-2 during the preseason to find a back up plan for a Sydney FC shorn of Nicky Carle. With a fully fit marquee man the Sydney diamond was restored and after a stifled opening, Carle slotted comfortably in behind the gifted Alex Brosque and Mark Bridge. The results were more than encouraging.
Sydney’s first choice B-B-C frontline is technically adroit, reasonably hard-working and comfortable working without the ball to find space. Each player can take on a man, hit the flanks, run a good line in behind the defence or hold up the ball in their own way.
Karol Kisel will remain a Sydney FC hero but Carle surpassed Kisel's erratic contributions by providing some welcome composure and true creativity. And while the Cove’s fantastic banners at the start of the match hailed the contribution of Steve Corica, by fulltime the boys in blue were praising their eternal skipper’s true successor. Carle is a genuine playmaker, a genuine marquee and a number 10 to match Carlos Hernandez and Jason Culina. His flicks and tricks won him the space and time to pick a pass and the growing admiration of a responsive crowd. Melbourne eventually stood off him after he defied any attempt to put him off the ball and his game.
Frankly, if Carle plays that well throughout the season, Sydney will tear at least one team apart at the seams and it was a shame that his match-controlling performance did not produce more goals.
Bridge and Brosque did well without breaking the game open and one senses that if Lavicka had signed a third striker Bridge would have been substituted halfway through the second half. Sydney FC has never really enjoyed the services of a Smeltz-like predator and the club is now blessed with creativity. What Sydney need is someone to smash the ball into the back of the net and hopefully Bridge will become that man. After all, it would surprise if Sydney can generate that many good chances against Melbourne again this season.
Sadly for Sydney, an A League match is rarely won by the front men. Two of Melbourne’s three goals (and, to be fair, two of Sydney’s) were mostly the result of poor positioning and decision-making in possession and then defence. Only two Victory players hit the box for the cross that led to their first goal, but both outfoxed five Sydney defenders. Mate Dugandzic’s equalising strike was well-taken but he did not have a foot, hand or body near him when he first received the ball. And the third goal resembled a FIFA 2006 play as Melbourne passed their way through the Sydney midfield and defence with consummate ease.
The rot started at the front as Sydney forgot to close down collectively after their second goal. With Carle drawn forward and Brosque and Bridge wide, Scott Jamieson got unsurprisingly lost as part of a three-man holding midfield. Sydney’s flanks were exposed and the central defenders seemed unsure of whether to tag and follow or pass on their man. Jamieson had an unhappy match crowned by an air swing at a beckoning strike on goal, but his preseason form was encouraging and he will find his feet.
At least Sydney were assured when they could put their foot on the ball. The Victory missed a number of first-team players but apart from Melbourne’s seven minutes of madness, Sydney almost totally dominated the match and enforced their will from back to front.
Skipper Terry McFlynn played a strong game and took his goal well, while Stuart Musialik put in his usual performance: an excellent, controlling game apart from one or two dreadful errors that put his team under pressure. Musialik is a vital player for Sydney and when he returned to the side last season the Sky Blues rocketed towards glory. If he can continue to reduce his errors in possession he should again find himself in the frame for the Socceroos.
Another man who delivered welcome composure was Hayden Foxe. Foxe slipped straight into Simon Colosimo’s quarterback role and looks to be a marvellous acquisition. But with a Keller/Foxe partnership Sydney clearly lack pace in central defence. If Lavicka sticks with this combination he will be stretching his tactical blanket like mad. It will be fascinating to see how Lavicka can sit his team high and play a short passing game with overlapping fullbacks and simultaneously cover runs from fast strikers with a fairly plodding central defensive combination.
Presumably Foxe will miss games due to injury and recovery and the burden will fall heavily on Seb Ryall, who is yet to convince. Ryall put in a good shift at right back and offered a surprising threat in attack, but was caught out of position during several of Melbourne’s lethal moments. Shannon Cole will rightfully push him all the way this season and will probably start games against lesser teams than Melbourne.
On the other side, it is perhaps best to simply say that Jamieson and Byun worked hard on the pitch but have work to do off it.
Much more has been said elsewhere about the "disappointing" crowd. I was stunned when the figure of 12,000 came up – it felt that at least 16,000 were in the stadium. The crowd enjoyed a fantastic atmosphere, thrilling goals, some brilliant skill – mostly from Carle – and a passionate match that was laudably contested through ball-on-the-ground, short passing football. I was disappointed by the people who didn't turn up, including the other 12,000 Sydney fans who made it to the Valentine's Day fixture, or some of the 40,000 who went to the Everton match, but couldn't be bothered watching Sydney's opener. Those who were there were fantastic and deserved the spectacle they received.
So if you know a Sydney football fan, buy them a ticket for August 28. Because Carle and company are well worth the meagre price of admission.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)